By Anna Merlan
By Lee Escobedo
By Alice Laussade
By Scott Reitz
By Claire Lawton
By Kiernan Maletsky
By Anna Merlan
With Henry Fool, he's trying to make his first film that starts with a specific environment and looks at its effect on the film's protagonists; by contrast, Hartley's past films have always had a distinctive, even problematic relationship to their settings. The director hails from Lindenhurst, Long Island, and most of his films are shot or set in the island's suburbs or in the city that looms over them. ("Most of my personality comes from there," he assures; he describes his parents as "Long Island pioneers" who pointed their wagons east "when suburbias were growing like mushrooms right after the war.") Hartley has rarely budged from the orbit of Manhattan--after a youth in which "I was almost unconscious, I was so shy," he went to college at the State University of New York at Purchase, where his focus shifted from music to art to film.
Despite the director's real-life geographic grounding, there's precious little to locate us in most Hartley films; this sense of floating in space adds to a disorientation produced by his movies' flat tones. (He's especially fond of long shots of banal, unromantic desolation; "I've always got my eye out for flat spaces to have someone fall down on," he has said. "Empty highways have this almost narcotic attraction for me.") The lack of any sense of place in Hartley's films is deliberate.
"I didn't want to be culturally or geographically specific," he says of his use of locales. "I've always strived for the general. It was a little frustrating in the early films--'the director from Long Island.' I wanted to talk about American culture, not my particular neighborhood."
His characteristic locale is a postmodern American nowhere--set on Long Island, but with no local color and little that's culturally or geographically distinguishing. With Henry Fool, he still offers few cues, but he's shooting to highlight the space, much as experimental composers write pieces that explore the acoustics of their rooms or studios. "I'd always been dissatisfied with one aspect of my filmmaking, which was rendering environments. It was really a matter of making shots that weren't establishing shots--but that were meaningful and established setting."
Hartley tried a similar experiment with Flirt. That film, which felt almost like an empty exercise, was built of three almost identical romantic scenarios set in New York, Berlin, and Tokyo. His conclusion, coming off Flirt: "I have to remember that when I go home to make films, I need to shoot my home as if it's a foreign locale." Hence Henry Fool, shot only a few miles from scenic Lindenhurst. One day, coming back from visiting his father on Long Island, he got off the subway in Woodside, Queens, planning to just look around and do some thinking. But he was fascinated by the place, "visually and ethnically," and struck by Woodside's incongruous cross "between Mayberry and an inner-city 'hood."
"With this film I set myself a problem, and that was, 'What would cinema verite be like if you couldn't move the camera?'" Some things he and longtime cinematographer Mike Spiller kept deliberately out of focus; they shot other scenes from unlikely angles or held shots for uncomfortable stretches of time. Hartley says he was "first responding to the environment, to the space." For some of his shots, he said, "I had to convince the crew that I wasn't kidding."
Besides handling the camera differently, he's altered his casting for Henry Fool. Most of his movies feature Martin Donovan, an actor Hartley discovered working in New York avant-garde theater; Donovan, with his combination of brooding, almost somnambulant good looks and nervous physical energy, has become a hallmark of the director's work and has had some success elsewhere. (He appeared most recently in The Opposite of Sex.) Henry Fool has no Donovan, but puts Posey, an old college friend who has had minor roles in other Hartley films, in a starring role. The film's two male leads are Thomas Jay Ryan (Henry) and James Urbaniak (Simon); the latter looks like the bastard offspring of James Joyce and Samuel Beckett. Both Ryan and Urbaniak, downtown New York theater guys, make their film debut with Henry Fool. (Donovan, Ryan, and British rocker Polly Jean Harvey have recently completed a Biblical allegory called The Book of Life, of which Jessie Helms is unlikely to approve.) In his casting, as in his choice of locales, Hartley says, "I go for generality; I like archetypes."
So why all this strangeness? People falling down, goofy-looking folks, weird camera angles, Godardian speechifying, and Bressonian gestures? Hartley has said that his films are designed to counter the country's growing homogenization, that they're as bold as they are because they're meant to disturb the peace. Despite their mostly hetero settings, he sees them as the cinematic equivalent of ACT-UP's trouble-making: "films that consciously impede a good night's sleep."
The result is a movie about a garbageman's poetry becoming the latest youth craze. "If poetry was as popular with high school kids as rock and roll," Hartley says of the movie's premise. "That's the science-fiction element of the film."
All in all, though, he says he's made Henry Fool a "very realistic film." "Our actual culture," he says," is much more surreal.
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!
Find everything you're looking for in your city
Find the best happy hour deals in your city
Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%
Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city