Brown October

A lesson on how not to musically suck--just act the exact opposite of these turds

Houston's Blue October has sold out a spacious venue just weeks after the spectacular 80-some-odd band Wall of Sound Festival did not, proving that the metroplex is confused about which bands suck and which bands don't. In our ever-vigilant effort to get your heads straight, here are five signs that a band might really, really suck, presented as a public service:

1. The lead singer wears eyeliner. Robert Smith might get away with it because he's been doing it longer than most B.O. fans have been alive (though that actually seems like a good reason to quit). But My Chemical Romance and Good Charlotte have proven there is a direct correlation between allowing a dude in your band to wear black eyeliner and sucking. There may be exceptions, but Blue October is not one of them.

2. The band has a violinist...not a fiddler, but a violinist. Fort Worth's Alan might be the exception that proves this rule, but normally violins and rock go together like personal hygiene and Devendra Banhart. If you have to ask, "What about Dave Matthews Band, bro?" put down this paper and get back to your hacky-sack game.

3. The band's songwriter has ever said anything like, "It's like, let me just kind of clue you in on what it feels like in my own brain." No need to tell me, I can already imagine. I bet it's nice in there, Justin Furstenfeld: roomy and probably furnished with enough dope residue from your overly confessed addictions to provide years of fun. If the first sentence in a band's official bio is how much he loves his record label and the second sentence is this kind of drivel, proceed with caution.

4. The guitarist constantly name-checks Steve Vai in interviews. Look, Brant Coulter, just because your guitar teacher supped from the buttholes of Vai and Satriani doesn't mean that you should try to sound like them. Nobody except a few guitar students wants to hear riffs that sound like they're played by robots. If you think that's cool, maybe you should put a guitar pick in your mouth and stick out your tongue for every promo pic just like Vai did. Better yet, maybe you should pour Drano into a mixing bowl and put your hands in it until they dissolve. Your screams would be more pleasant than your licks.

5. The songs feature junior-high diary lyrics and histrionically over-emoted singing. Really, this could be simplified to "having anything to do with the song 'Hate Me.'" Lines like "I have to block out thoughts of you, so I don't lose my head/They crawl in like a cockroach leaving babies in my bed" make it hard to resist the easy jab of the song title. Cockroaches lay eggs. Juvenile cockroaches are larvae, not babies. And how can plural thoughts behave like a singular...never mind. Those two lines are so confusing, I don't know where to begin.

 
  • R Himes 07/26/2011 3:22:00 PM

    Are you serious? The first comment of this article says it all! You obviously dont like Blue October and refuse to open your mind to the idea that thousands do. Only a piss poor journalist would deny proven fact over his own opinion.

  • brant coulter 08/29/2010 9:10:00 PM

    Brant Coulter here. People have been calling me over the past couple of years asking if I can teach them how to play guitar like Steve Vai and if I rejoined Blue October. I have now discovered the reason. The answer is no and no. Haven't been in the band since early 2000's and don't like Steve Vai all that much; evident in the fact that I'm not that good of a guitar player and never wore leather pants. Coincidently, I have immersed my hands in Drano on numerous prior occasions- it seemed to make sense at the time. Please pass the word that I will not be available for shred fests and autographs. Sincerely, not C.B. Hudson.

  • Steve 04/09/2009 8:47:00 AM

    Jesse- you are the fratboy you fu**ing LoSeR!

  • Jesse Hughey 06/18/2007 7:14:00 PM

    Another exception to the violins rule: Nouns Group. One letter-writer said that I don't have the right to trash the band because I haven't seen them live. Actually, I have. It was years ago at SXSW, long before they adopted the Gothy-come-lately mascara and instead just dressed like frat-boy douchebags. They opened for Cracker and Camper Van Beethoven. It was the only time in my life that I've ever heckled and thrown things at a band. They were awful, and I am not ashamed of my behavior. It was announced Friday that John Lomax at the Houston Press won Best Music Criticism in the AAN awards. One of his contest entries was an essay attempting to distance his city from this band.

  • Kate 02/22/2007 12:07:00 AM

    Hello-- Just responding to your article on Blue, which I miraculously managed to avoid in my travels around the every clutterd world of "pompous crap" that you seem to be clinging to, don't get me confused with one of your ilk, locals I mean, I was just passing through and got so befuddled by the idiocy that I could'nt find my way out. Anyway, "everyone's right to their own opinion" is my banner right now, and although yours is based on half baked ideas that you know what music is and isn't, I guess I have to respect it, however, I will make mine clear. Violins are a musical instrument and have a place in the composition of music, incidently, the career path of 5 talented men from Texas...and clearly not yours. When you say anything about drivel I hope you take into account the BS you are pouring out like some sort of Rock God Sermon, I don't think there is anything to that BUT drivel. I have said it before and I will say it again, it takes more spine to own up to mistakes and to face the flaws that every other human may try to hide. It takes more understanding to say, I think your flaws are beautiful and it takes more talent to move a person with "junior high diary lyrics" than to make them angry with words that make no sense and are screamed into your ear like a drill digging for the last vestiges of intelligence in an otherwise close-minded wasteland. I am a fan first and a analyst later, you should try it and find that music can be beautiful again. Thank you for your time

  • Jessica 02/21/2007 11:00:00 PM

    I love Blue October, but this article did make me laugh a few times. Both at the imagery, and the fact that you don't think violins go with rock and roll. I agree that this last album wasn't the best out of what they've done, but I will stand behind the band and the other albums because they are unique and very talented. I agree Justin seems over the top from time to time, but most lead vocalists are. I haven't met one that isn't yet. It goes along with being the lead vocalist. Just like fighter pilots are all egotistical, lead vocalists have their own persona to fill as well. Say what you like about Blue October, but they do reach a lot of people, whether it's for the wrong or right reason is not for us to say.

  • Jessica 02/21/2007 4:46:00 PM

    I would like to say, as a Blue October fan, that you have a right to your opinion. But to say that its ok for some people to wear eyeliner, but some not? That's not right. They sell out for a reason, they have fans, people that listen to their music and enjoy it. It is good music, and if you knew the whole story of Blue October and where they came from instead of judging them without reading then you would understand, and not be so harsh with your words.

 

Most Popular Stories

Find a Concert

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy