SXSW, WTF?

Things change, and that's fine, but can we get some love for the good bands?

As reported on many blogs across the DFW musical world, the list of local bands accepted as official artists for this year's South by Southwest festival came out recently. It was critically panned by bloggers, hipsters and everyone in between, and I gotta say, I'm right there with 'em.

That's not meant as a dis to any of the groups who made it; Midlake, Fair to Midland, Hourly Radio—all of them deserve their selection. It's the omissions that are shocking. No Baboon? Sure they've played SXSW before, but in this land of excellent and underrated bands, Baboon is arguably the best of them all, and they deserve a spot.

Like most of you, I've been attending South by Southwest for years. It often coincided with spring break, so in high school and college, a quick trip down Interstate 35 was all the itinerary I needed. In the beginning, SXSW was a smallish affair, very insider-y in the sense that only people who deeply cared about music cared about the festival. Its purpose was primarily geared toward shining a light on unsigned bands of whom no one had ever heard. It was an attempt to maybe get these bands a record deal, and not much more. For a while it was pretty easy to get into any SXSW show, keynote speakers were Texas musicians and there was no damn interactive festival.

But of course, things change. The evolution of SXSW into the goliath it is today might or might not have been inevitable, but once its momentum started it was difficult to stop. Record companies started to get real excited, and they started to pay attention. They started to send their people down to Central Texas in ever-increasing numbers. After a few years, you couldn't find a hotel room downtown in the middle of March, when Austin became infested with badge-slinging, cell-phone-yammering, name-dropping label people who overtook the sidewalks like cockroaches.

Nowadays, you can't find a hotel room within a 50-mile radius of Austin during SXSW, and the cockroaches have multiplied like...uh, cockroaches, along with music journalists, international press, MTV camera crews and those interactive fest people. It's all laptops and BlackBerrys and Levi's jeans sponsoring free tequila parties where there aren't even any bands.

All of which is OK—it's got its good and its bad, but, despite Levi's, almost every square foot of the town is devoted to a stage, and it's still pretty amazing to see music take over a city. It's analogous to Deep Ellum in that it will never be the same as what it once was, and once we can accept that, maybe we can figure out a way to celebrate what it has become.

The problem with SXSW, however, is that its own success has so inverted what its original purpose was that bands such as Baboon get left out, and that's where I get angry. The main problem is not how monstrous the festival has become, or how its insider-y nature now manifests in a celebrity/major record executive/giant music superstar nexus of hobnobbing. The main problem is that it is filled with bands we've already heard of, who already have fat record contracts, and the lesser-knowns and local groups who really deserve attention are given short shrift.

Fortunately, all the satellite showcases and non-sanctioned shows (the best of which was the now-defunct Fuck by Fuck You showcase) are primo spots for finding new, quality music. Keep an eye on this column, And Another Thing and Unfair Park in the next few weeks, as we'll be giving you the low-down on those shows as they're booked. Meantime, keep your head up, Baboon. Maybe next year.

 
  • Glen Reynolds 02/25/2007 7:49:00 AM

    I sort of overestimated Chomsky's 4 sold out appearances @ SXSW between 2001-2004. I thought surely as a primary contributor to Chomsky I could get in. With a new album of songs that seemed to me to be on the same level as AFPSFTSOYL, the first record to sound like the Strokes before the Strokes did, how could the festival not recognize that? Well, #1, I now understand how little I am in the Universe of Indie. But I thought that the festival was made to help out burgeoning acts, you say? Well, nope. Factoid #2 is that SXSW is now and has been organized of late simply to make itself bigger, better, and more wealthy. How else could you explain the fact that all out of US acts have a separate application for the festival. While applying you get the feeling that you are standing on the other side of the velvet ropes, only at this club you pay the cover while you then wait hopelessly in line. Luckily, I'm 34 and could give Peter Schmidt's pessimism a run for it's money,(I love you Peter) so I shed no tears over it. But you make a great point about Baboon. This is a band that only gets better with age. Baboon started out as an art rock band, but curiously now appears to be more of a Stratovarius violin- they only get better and better with age! Boohoo to SXSW, who appear to be no better than house-flippers. Turning around already successful acts for their own profit while contributing nothing to the betterment of the industry they purport to support.

  • David 02/16/2007 2:50:00 PM

    "Like most of you, I've been attending South by Southwest for years." Lucky you. That's a nice bubble you live in. :) Do you think most people have the kind of money to attend this monstrosity? It's not cheap. I went last year, but I didn't buy a wristband. I had one band I wanted to see... dEUS from Belgium. dEUS hasn't toured in the United States in ten years. I drove down there for one night only. My plans was to camp out and hope for the best. Turns out one of the band members got me in. The people from SXSW treated them like crap. The sound tech person was incompetent and an asshole. As a result, they were an hour behind and due to Austin's curfew restrictions -- it cut dEUS' set short. SXSW is a bloated hipster orgy. Keep Austin Weird? Austin sold its soul to MTV and Red Bull.

  • Justin Lloyd 02/15/2007 11:37:00 PM

    I'm in several bands that applied to SXSW this year, and not one of us expected to get in. 3 of them are going to be in Austin to play house parties, a non-SXSW affiliated label showcase, and to have a good time. The reason we applied was out of almost obligation. Who wouldn't? The reason for our pessimism? Because SXSW is a music festival that has to make its money back just like any festival in the world. Why would they pick our band, Baboon, any other band in Texas, to play a festival in Austin? The bands that play there have to be a) buzzed enough, b) exotic enough, or c) established enough to get people to want to come thousands of miles to see them. Its hard enough for REALLY GOOD Dallas bands to pack a room in Austin. (Hell, its hard enough to pack a room in DALLAS.) Its just like how most of the booking agencies around here function: SXSW organizers pick bands based on their ability to fill a room and sell wristbands. Otherwise, you're dirt. It has little to do with "talent." In conclusion, don't try and glorify SXSW (or acceptance into SXSW) for something it's not. Maybe it was once a place for unknown bands to get a jump-start on a career in music, but unless you run a label rich enough to pay for a showcase that no one will attend, you're only going to play there if you can sell wristbands. I'd say the majority of musicians realize this. I don't mean to critize you personally by any means. Just wanted to throw that out there.

 

Most Popular Stories

Find a Concert

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy