A Devil's Deal in Dallas Court

A terrible crime plus skaky evidence tempts prosecutors to play a secret game of "let's make a deal"

The revelation that his Pillsbury Doughboy was a vicious rapist "kind of ruined my weekend," says Loving, now a federal prosecutor in San Antonio. "For 20 years I thought I'd gotten an innocent person off."

Warder says she was "extremely disappointed" to hear about the DNA test. "He duped me. He lied in court, and the jury believed him. He fooled a lot of sophisticated people. Looking back, I certainly wish we had the benefit of what we have now."

In semi-retirement after losing the last election, Warder isn't convinced that Chabot had nothing to do with the crime.

Chabot remains in a Texas prison while Craig Watkins decides if the case against him will be dismissed. Even if the case isn't dismissed, Chabot will get a new trial.

"What's important is now, regardless of what happened back then, we've arrested and charged Pabst and we intend to try him," says Mike Ware, special assistant in charge of conviction integrity, a post newly created by Watkins. "And if we make any deals in this case or any other case, they are going to be disclosed and they are going to be aboveboard."

« Previous Page
My Voice Nation Help