How to Be a Good Cover Band

If you'd asked two years ago, I would have said that the only reason for a cover band to exist is to make money and watch the crazy shit that goes down at weddings, and that's coming from someone who's been in one. Yeah, I admit it—the Ronnie Dobbs Band could "rock your corporate event" with hits from Coldplay to Heart. We were never meant to write our own material or go any further than holiday parties at local venues. I also got total shit for being in a cover band. It's a stigma. "You don't do any original music?" "Oh God, you have to sing 'Lights' by Journey?!" Looking back now, those were fun times, but the jokes and snarking also turned me into a snob. Tribute nights are one thing, but professional cover bands became a whole new cancer for me.

After realizing that in 10 rehearsals or less, one could master a set of covers, I discovered that if a band was simply a cover band all the time the lack of effort would be infuriating. There'd be no satisfaction from an audience loving an original song. You'd simply be a fat cash-earning conduit for blasts from the pasts, and I didn't see any honor in taking listeners back to their days at the skating rink, bellbottoms or the night they lost their virginity. There are DJs for that.

The King Bucks' talent isn't buried underneath the covers.
holly robison
The King Bucks' talent isn't buried underneath the covers.

All that held until I ran into the King Bucks. Via covers and (gasp!) the occasional original tune, the King Bucks will take you (or me, specifically) back to Dad teaching how to pop a beer top, sitting in Granny's kitchen at that cool metal table and insisting that brown cowboy boots needed to be worn with an Easter dress. Somehow those blasts aren't as offensive when done with reverence for the original musicians such as Buck Owens (hence the name), the Louvin Brothers, the Everly Brothers, Waylon Jennings, Hank Thompson, David Allan Coe, Dylan and the like. As King Buck Chad Stockslager says, "It's not a tribute to a band as much as a style or genre. It's a time-honored sound."

Before there's any question as to why the Bucks break the cover band mold, let's get the history out of the way. Those of you aware of Dallas/Denton music from the last decade will remember a little outfit called Budapest One. After the demise of that group came the Drams—who play packed houses (such as New Year's Eve with the Old 97's) and claim a couple of the same members as Budapest One. Said Drams—Keith Killoren and Stockslager—began a weekly Wednesday night set at the Barley House.

Between the two of them, Killoren and Stockslager have been in about 1,279 bands. Not really, of course, but their studio-quality skills are often borrowed and loaned out for friends' recordings and live performances. In the same vein, Killoren & Stockslager started hosting some regular guests at their performances: Joseph Butcher (UFOFU, Pleasant Grove, Polyphonic Spree and 917 other bands), Danny Balis (Sorta, Sparrows, 313 others) and Chris Carmichael (Airline, Sorta, 189 others).

The King Bucks were made official in September of last year. "We played our first gig as a full band at Mesquite Rodeo. People there thought we were too loud. We were," says Butcher after the Bucks performed during the Boys Named Sue's "House of Sues" night to a healthy crowd at House of Blues...an audience probably a bit more prepared for the decibels than the God and Garth Brooks-fearing rodeo folk.

The Bucks' performances include an impressive yet tried and true honky-tonk-style rotation of Stockslager, Killoren, Balis and Butcher on main vocals in addition to their normal duties on keys, guitar, bass and pedal steel, respectively. All members contribute to the playlist of originals and covers.

Stockslager says the simplicity of the honky-tonk song structure makes it both a pleasure to cover and an inspiration from which to craft original tunes. "Think of Ernest Tubb. The structure of his songs is so simple...you can't listen to that stuff and not be affected by it. It's as simple as that," he says. "Keith and I were working on a song the other day, and the structure is so bare-bones you can hang anything off it and just go for broke."

The Bucks toss in three or four original songs per set. Some of them have been around since Budapest One; others are new inventions that Butcher describes as "rip-offs of other songs we like, albeit obscure ones."

"We've had these songs we've been wanting to play, but we needed a proper outfit for them, so we've been working them in piece by piece," Stockslager says. "I think there's a growing need for these original songs," he adds, before making an observation that pretty much sums up my entire point about the Bucks.

He explains how they are lucky to be a band of people devoted to the honky-tonk song—which encompasses a great many elements, tempos, emotions and sounds. He says that while there's an expectation of the honky-tonk band to show up and play songs people can dance to, those dances can be slow, fast, mid-tempo. They can be sad, celebratory or romantic. "There's a fine line. Boys Named Sue are a great band and a blast to watch, but if they tried to do a song that breaks your heart it wouldn't work," Stockslager says. The King Bucks work within a range in which the Everlys, George Jones and David Allan Coe can all find a home. Thus, they can throw in an original inspired by any of the old standards they perform, and as long as they're true to the emotion of the honky-tonk, it too will find a welcome.

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • Milt 08/07/2011 6:33:00 AM

    If playing other people's music is such a bad thing, then why do well established artists publish their music to be played by the general public aside from making money?Why bother to publish songbooks...original scores, easy play editions, sheet music and all that? Many bands start out playing other people's music and go from there with their own stuff, but nothing says that bands have to play their own stuff. The music industry is a business and the bottom line is to make money. Tribute bands and cover bands are here and fill a niche, a very lucurative one; there is nothing that says they cannot. I do agree with you that playing someone else's music does stiffle creativity and originality but not everyone who loves music can compose and write lyrics and this is where the less talented or less motivated musicians/singers can be found. The field of music is very accommodating to various levels of talent from the really bad to the exceptional even when it comes to Tribute and Cover bands. Nor can one ignor the harsh reality of economics: If you can't make money to eat off your own musical creations, then you are forced to play what your customers want to hear if you are going to eat. I wonder how the music scene would be different if there was more of a demand for original music that cover music? Furthermore, there are people that are quite content and happy just to play covers and who says that they can't? These people are free to do as they wish. Let's face it, people like to hear what is familiar to them. just as much as people like to play what is familiar to them. It is human nature and people are creatures of habit which sounds like the problem that you are having in the Dallas area. As you say, it may be excrement that everyone has heard before; however, this excrement is something that people are willing to pay good money in spite of ASCAP fees. So, the issue really is how to break the habits of the public to be more receptive to new music and how to encourage bands in the area to introduce this new music and still keep it lucurative for these bands to do so. I do see how a hoard of tribute and cover bands in a local area could choke out and limit the variation of bands wanting to introduce new music to the public. If that is the point of your contention with Tribute and Cover bands, then I agree with you.

  • Chromepolisher 06/21/2011 10:06:00 PM

    http://coverbandconnection.blogspot.com/

  • Zara 09/03/2008 1:19:00 PM

    If you're getting paid to perform then you give the customer what they want, period. Putting in your own material turns it into art. Only acceptable if either 1) you're not getting paid or 2) the customer wants art. This has worked for me and I've been pro ever since I left school 35 years ago. I'm still going strong (and yes, I suppose I am good-looking).

  • Dr. Evil 08/08/2008 7:39:00 PM

    What is this crap? This article is not informative at all to the reader. It's a personal history of one yahoo's experience in a band in Dallas. This was article was not written well in my opinion.

  • Matt... again 02/12/2008 12:22:00 AM

    Good to see everyone agrees. :)

  • Matt 01/31/2008 10:29:00 PM

    Correction... There's NO way to be a good cover band. Fuck a cover band. Fuck a tribute band. Period. This is why the Dallas music scene sucks, people--- and don't act like it doesn't. It's cool to play covers, but if you're playing more covers than originals, you're an embarrassment to live music. These kinds of bands may be talented, but they might as well be Britney Spears, Jessica or Ashley Simpson. Why? because sure you can perform someone else's creation for a check, but you don't have the BALLS (or ability) to play the majority of your own material because you may not get as good of a crowd response, or as good of a venue, or as big of a check. Tribute/cover bands that have KILLED the Dallas music scene....and made our city to believe that going to see a live band means going to hear a cover band, and that the goal of a band in Dallas should be to learn other "more famous" bands' material. Once musicians start weening the sheep-like Dallas public off of the idea that "If I haven't hummed this music with my car radio before, I don't care to listen to it." mentality, a "Dallas Music Scene" worth mentioning may actually begin to exist. So, all you Dallas musicians out there! Take your balls out of your mother's coin purse, and start playing your own music. Stop feeding the ridiculous unoriginal minds of Dallas Suburbia with shit everyone has heard before, and stop filling ASCAPS pockets. Make Dallas a place where people actually want to hear live music. Feel free to take notes on this issue from Austin or Denton... ANY night of the week. p.s. This wasn't directed specifically at the band named in the article, just "cover/tribute" bands in general.

  • frilth 01/17/2008 11:05:00 PM

    and if you don't pay ASCAP you can get a one sided ass kissing article later

  • CrotchPunch 01/17/2008 3:45:00 PM

    "Still, there are rules, and here are King Buck Joe Butcher's regulations for being in a Dallas cover band, or this one, anyway: 1. Band members should be good-looking. Nobody wants to be forced to look at unattractive people for any length of time. Good looks trump actual talent any day." ...which begs the question - what the hell are half those guys doing anywhere near that band? I guess pasty and waifish or trucker-chic is the new good-looking.

 

Most Popular Stories

Find a Concert

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy