DISD's Confederacy of Jerks

Extremely pushy parents—Latino, black and Anglo—must rise up to save DISD from itself

If Obama can be president, is it OK for white people to be assholes again?

And, of course, I don't mean it exactly the way it sounds. I'm worried about the Dallas school system. What I really mean is that it may be time for upwardly mobile middle-class and working-class people of all ethnicities in the city to step forward and fight the good fight for old-fashioned academic elitism again.

You know what I mean by elitism—courses like calculus. That old, snobby numbers game. Or Latin, the language of empire. How about literacy—by which I mean people who do read, as opposed to people who can.

Have we come far enough for restlessly ambitious parents to begin demanding excellence in the schools again and suffer whatever slings and arrows may come their way as a result?

I would hope that black parents will be assholes as well. And Latino parents. I would include Asian parents, but we all know that's not going to happen.

Obnoxious, pushy, child-worshipping, sidelines-screaming, over-competitive, wildly insecure but arrogant parents with rat-like determination to get what they want for their kids: How do we get those people back involved in an urban school district, as opposed to the goofy morons and bandits running the place into the grave today?

We can't afford to let the suburbs have all the pushy jerks. We need to lure some of them back. Otherwise, too few people will ever give a damn.

Let me make the first part of my case here with a simple number—627. That is the number of votes that swept Dallas school trustee Adam Medrano into office last May 10 in the district's only contested school board race. Medrano trounced his sole challenger, Pedro Alvarez, with 627 votes to Alvarez's 178.

Think about it. My son went to Woodrow Wilson High School. The published student population at Woodrow is 1,470. If every student at Woodrow voted, Medrano's tally wouldn't have been enough to get him elected prom queen. So instead he's a trustee over the whole district.

Please don't take this as a slur aimed at Medrano. At least he cares enough to go down there and give a big slice of his life to public service at school headquarters. It's not his fault the rest of us are such slouches.

I argued in a column last week (so I won't argue again) that the absence of parents and other citizens from the political process in the school district leaves DISD in the hands of two interest groups: 1) district staff, and 2) construction industry companies involved in school bond building campaigns.

Those two groups, the staff and the builders, have a right to be heard. But no decent pushy parent should be willing to leave the fate of his or her child in the hands of a coalition of bureaucrats and builders. Are you kidding? Better to send the kid down to the bus station with a few bucks for lunch and a comic book.

But don't do that. I have a better idea.

We do live in a democracy, after all. There is no reason why parents couldn't have an impact on school board elections and in that way exert a powerful influence on the schools. I wrote last week about Texas Parent PAC, a political action committee that has enjoyed remarkable success in state legislative races since its founding in 2005.

The non-partisan Parent PAC raises money which it puts into targeted legislative contests, endorsing and supporting Republican and Democratic candidates who support good schools. In several tightly contested races, up against opponents with huge financial support from the anti-public education ideologues, Parent PAC candidates have prevailed.

So why couldn't we do that here in school board races? Last week I spoke with Carolyn Boyle, founder and chair of Parent PAC, who explained to me that her group doesn't have the resources at this point to get involved in local school board races.

"But I do think we are modeling for people that parents can really get involved and create political action committees, and that should happen, really, at school board levels."

But somebody has to do it.

"The problem is, it takes someone stepping forward," Boyle said. "With Texas Parent PAC, that was me."

She thinks women are better candidates than men for this sort of thing. "People have commented to me that really the only people who could have done what Parent PAC has done were a bunch of PTA moms, because men would be too scared that it would flop, and they would lose face."

I concede there is no more implacable force in nature than mothers, but I do think fathers could serve at least in a subordinate role.

So why doesn't it happen here? I know from my own family's experience in the Dallas schools that there are pockets of parents clustered around a few favored schools who will make almost any sacrifice in time and effort for the sake of those schools. Why haven't those long-lost cadres of committed parents stepped forward from the gloom, especially at a time like this, to do something powerful and effective like form a political action committee to clean up DISD?

1 | 2 | 3 | Next Page >>
 
  • Matt 11/25/2008 6:34:00 PM

    "Schutze, until people like you, Angela Hunt and the city staff quit fighting development (i.e. the "hated McMansions") in Dallas, the parents you so desperately want to move in and support the school system ain't coming. They won't live in the little pasteboard houses you all are trying to save. These families, with 2 or more kids, want up to date homes with nice kitchens, large closets and more than two bedrooms...and a two- or three-car garage. As long as you guys fight the developers at every turn and try to crucify the McMansion buyers, they will stay away. Are you willing to lighten up to get them to come here? Nah, didn't think so" Um.... the McMansioners are moving here in droves... and yet nothing is better in DISD. You see, all the McMansioners are STILL sending their kids to private schools. You make a terrible point. Just had to call you out on it real quick. There are plenty of concerned parents that live in 'pasteboard houses', you pompous douchebag.

  • Americano 10/26/2008 8:11:00 AM

    There are dedicated parents in the DISD, just not very many of them. Most are probably spending more time worrying about what they can get for free, from those evil rich people, and don't have time to spend with their kids, or pushing their local school to get better. A little discipline and work ethic on the parents part would go a long way. On a more positive note, Jim you are the Grand Marshall in the jerk parade, so smile and wave!

  • Another fred 10/24/2008 1:40:00 AM

    Some of those private schools are little more than white flight academies - true there are some good ones and everyone knows which ones they are -- when will any of the others even produce a NMSF? In any case, those kids will not be prepared for the real world, which is not like Highland Park. Some people call all DISD schools terrible, and would rather shell out private school tuition than even cross the door of the local public school to investigate. Now, who is stupid? DISD schools aren't all good but there are many in Dallas which can compete with the best private and suburban schools. In most cases these are the ones with AP and TAG programs - so if you don't check it out, you won't find them. Believe me we are loudly protesting in East Dallas. We shall survive this administration. We shall not abandon our schools. We care about all children, not just Buffy and Biff in HP or the private schools. They are our neighbors and our friends. And they will be for life. Hell hath no fury like a Lakewood mom. In the battle, they are tried and true. I would place my bet on them over 3700 Ross.

  • Billy 10/24/2008 1:10:00 AM

    Jim, Great article. I think one thing standing in the way of parents getting involved is the sheer size of DISD. Break up DISD into twenty or thirty pieces. One high school, two middle schools, and four elementary schools per district. Each district designed to be a majority minority district (should be doable since the district has over 90% minority enrollment.) Very flat organizational structure. Big districts are difficult to run in the best of times. DISD cannot and will not be reformed. Dismantle DISD and the parents would step up. So would the neighborhoods. DISD is full of solid hard working teachers. They would rejoice at DISD's demise. Take up the cause. I'll even run for school board.

  • Fred 10/23/2008 8:57:00 PM

    Schutze, until people like you, Angela Hunt and the city staff quit fighting development (i.e. the "hated McMansions") in Dallas, the parents you so desperately want to move in and support the school system ain't coming. They won't live in the little pasteboard houses you all are trying to save. These families, with 2 or more kids, want up to date homes with nice kitchens, large closets and more than two bedrooms...and a two- or three-car garage. As long as you guys fight the developers at every turn and try to crucify the McMansion buyers, they will stay away. Are you willing to lighten up to get them to come here? Nah, didn't think so.

  • amhunt007 10/23/2008 7:14:00 PM

    Want the white parents in Dallas who care about education to step it up in DISD? First, you've got to convince them to pull their kids away from the excellent education they're getting in private school and subject them to a sub-par education in DISD for a few years. The white parents who care about their kid's educations turned their backs on DISD a long time ago. Quite frankly, you've got to give them a reason to fight for a system that they've already written off and resent paying taxes to every year. And the only way to do that is money. Remind the white residents of Dallas of the economic impact that DISD has on the city. We've lost 2 large corporate relocations (Boeing and one other) in the last 10 years because of DISD. Remind people of that and you'll find a way to get people who previously had no vested interest in DISD to care. Talking about kids and education just doesn't do it for everyone. Some people need to see the full picture to understand the bigger impact.

  • Amy S 10/23/2008 7:06:00 PM

    "White people have to be jerks. Black people have to be jerks. Latinos have to be jerks. Everybody has to be able to get mad at everybody. And everybody has to get over it and join together to fight for educational excellence. I know there are people out there in the community who would fill this bill. I have their phone numbers. But it's up to them. One of them must step forward, as Carolyn Boyle said, and be the one to make it happen." So cue the "Jim Schutze for School Board" campaign signs? Otherwise you're just debating why someone else won't solve the problem - which really solves nothing.

  • lorlee 10/23/2008 5:56:00 PM

    As someone who has run both City Council and School Board elections -- it wouldn't take a lot of money to elect a new school board. City Council races generally cost north of $100,000 -- In a school board race, we felt really lucky if we raised $20,000. That, of course, presupposes that you have candidates who want to run. It is a thankless job.

  • bryan west 10/23/2008 1:11:00 AM

    Isn't the problem with a parents PAC is that it inevitably ends up in the hands of bookburners with specific ideas on the origin of life and sex ed? Hopefully not. Should someone that does not live in the DISD attendance/taxation zone even be allowed on the school board? Doesn't their home value increase every time the DISD falters?

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy