For Whom the Toll Bells

The North Texas Tollway Authority exacts a stiff price for those who drive willy-nilly on its highways

Certain things you can do that might turn out very badly for you. Borrowing money from the Mafia, for example. Posing naked for a photographer who is a stranger.

But who worries about driving down a toll road? I can tell you who should: You!

Over the last several years I have received numerous phone calls, letters and e-mails from people complaining that they have been hit with huge, totally unexpected bills for unpaid tolls and associated fines.

For a long time, I brushed these aside. I thought, "Well, you know, people should pay their tolls."

But most of the people calling me don't sound like folks who regularly skip on restaurant tabs or jump over turnstiles. I made up my mind a few weeks ago that the next time I got one of these complaints, I would stop whatever I was doing and take a look. I didn't have long to wait. On a Monday morning I found a phone message from Rick Johns, a probation officer in Tarrant County.

Johns had just received a bill from the North Texas Tollway Authority for $337 for four trips on the President George Bush Turnpike, which runs from near the D/FW Airport east to the vicinity of Rowlett on Lake Ray Hubbard.

For the first trip, which he made a year and a half ago, he was charged at a rate of $3 in tolls and $100 in "administrative fees." The second trip, made about a year ago, was billed at $3 in tolls and $75 in fees. Another cruise down the PGBT the following day cost him $2 in tolls and 50 bucks in fees.

The most recent trip, his most expensive, was made last May and billed at $4 in tolls and $100 in fees.

According to Johns, this statement was the first notification of any kind telling him he owed the NTTA money. His claim—that this was a first notice—was backed up by the notice itself, of which he gave me a copy, and by the NTTA's own description of its billing practices when I called them. The NTTA didn't comment on Johns' case specifically.

Before I even venture into the question of the billing practices, let's you and I see if we can figure out how a normal, law-abiding citizen—a parole officer in this case—gets behind the eight-ball to the tune of three C-notes in unpaid toll road fees.

Johns drives to the Dallas side of the metropolitan area for his son's baseball games. He used to drive on the State Highway 121 tollway between Coppell and Lewisville.

There are no tollbooths on 121. Therefore it is not possible to pay your tolls as you go. Cameras along the way take pictures of you as you pass. If you do not have an electronic TollTag on your windshield connected to a credit card, the NTTA bills you by mail for the amount of your tolls.

Johns didn't have a Dallas-area TollTag. Didn't want one. Was happy to pay by mail. Did so. He even thought mistakenly that he was paying a little extra and didn't mind.

"I was under the impression that the toll may have been even 25 cents higher per toll by not stopping and paying, and I didn't have a problem with that."

He says he paid those bills when he got them. Never had a problem. So where did he do wrong? He started driving on another NTTA toll road—the President George Bush Turnpike. There, the rules are different.

As explained to me by NTTA spokeswoman Sherita Coffelt, the difference is that the PGBT does have tollbooths, while the 121 tollway does not. Coffelt said that wherever there are tollbooths, a motorist who does not have a TollTag must stop and pay cash. Where there are no tollbooths, a motorist does not have to stop and pay cash.

When a motorist is not required to stop and pay cash, he will be billed for the amount of his toll only. When he is required to stop and pay cash but does not, he's a toll jumper. He will be billed for the amount of his toll plus a $25 penalty called an "administrative fee."

No signs along the road warn motorists of this difference. Coffelt told me it's the motorist's obligation to know the rules.

Each skipped toll station incurs a new $25 administrative fee. On his jaunt down the PGBT last May, Johns passed by four toll stations, each one of which took a picture of his license plate and billed him for a $1 toll plus a $25 administrative fee. So four times $26 amounted to a bill for $104, a tab he racked up for 33 minutes of driving.

But wait. We're not done with the different rules on how to pay your toll. There is a third rule. On the Dallas North Tollway, you can pay cash, so if you don't have a TollTag you must pay cash, and if you don't pay cash you'll be billed for the tolls plus the $25 fees. But you can't pay cash.

Say what?

The Dallas North Tollway is a road where you can pay cash, so you have to pay cash, but if you enter the Dallas North Tollway at the main plaza at Wycliff close to downtown, you will notice that you can't pay cash. There are no tollbooths at Wycliff.

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • Cheryl Cantilli 02/15/2010 9:12:00 PM

    Is there anything we can do to fight this insanity. I don't mind paying for tolls and even a REASONABLE amount mailing fees (of course I never received my bill - until the collection notice came). I just believe that $5.85 in tolls and $100 for fees is ridiculous 275% mark up! THis has all started in Austin now as well. Austin Tollway does not require a license plate number when you perchase a toll tag and my daughter has been hit for a $7000 bill on a toll of $240. All because the toll tag was not reading properly and they were unable to connect it to her tag because her license plate was not in the system. I notice that when I purchased my NTTA toll tag (which I had to do to lower my fees to $95) they required a licese plate number. Is there someone in government that is looking at this?

  • Bob 11/26/2009 7:45:00 AM

    I was a victim of this toll problem. After unknowingly incurring a 65-cent toll as a tourist unfamiliar with this practice, Alamo Car Rental slapped a $10 "administrative fee" on me for paying my 65-cent fee. They did not warn me about any of this, because I am convinced it is a nice profit center for them. When I complained to Alamo, at first the customer rep offered to waive the fee "once in a lifetime", then came back on and told she had decided not to. When I politely expressed my frustation, she hung up on me. My advice: stay away from Alamo at DFW or if you do rent a car from them, be sure to ask about these tolls so that don't stick you with an unfair charge of $10.

  • R Brackett Plumbing 04/24/2009 10:57:00 PM

    we never travel toll ways until a recent job far away, never the less trying to figure out witch lane to get in to it was to late the wrong lane was choosen and now we are spending are time online to figure out what to do. By the way there are no instructions only tickets ans fines come to find out by the internet. So how much will we owe who knows, the mafia is cheaper less red tape.

  • Herschel Fitts 04/15/2009 1:48:00 AM

    A great piece... now if you'd just follow up with the piece about how this is only the beginning of toll road terrorism provided to you by your local, state, and federal wannabe thugs, paid for by your tax dollars.

  • Dwayne, Elam 03/02/2009 2:27:00 AM

    Yes I totally agree, NTTA has some stiff administrative fees, as they call them. I use the south bound toll road to wycliff as a last resort when I'm running late, or when I 75 is backed up. I don't have a toll tag, but I'm seriously considering buying one. To my understanding, the NTTA has the authority to issue warrants for unpaid tolls. On numerous occasions I have received statements stating that I owed for unpaid tolls, and the prior month I received a letter & returned check stating that my account was current. I think there are too many agencys involved in the process, & everone isn't communicating or don't have access to the systems to verify infomation. "DRIVERS BEWARE, NTTA IS A CASH CASH COW". Someone has to pay for it, guess who?

  • Matt 02/11/2009 7:15:00 PM

    Man... I actually HAVE a toll tag, and these idiots STILL sent me bills/late charges. I called them, and was like, "Hey, I have a tolltag, why are you sending me bills, and charging me late fees?!" They replied, "Oh, sorry sir, our mistake..." I guess it wouldn't have been their mistake if I had actually paid these bills. You have to babysit the NTTA if you don't want to get completely ripped off by them. Question every bill you get from these fools. http://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/0/411/RipOff0411563.htm

  • Matt 02/11/2009 7:14:00 PM

    Man... I actually HAVE a toll tag, and these idiots STILL sent me bills/late charges. I called them, and was like, "Hey, I have a tolltag, why are you sending me bills, and charging me late fees?!" They replied, "Oh, sorry sir, our mistake..." I guess it wouldn't have been their mistake if I had actually paid these bills. You have to babysit the NTTA if you don't want to get completely ripped off by them. Question every bill you get from these fools. http://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/0/411/RipOff0411563.htm

  • Nancy 02/05/2009 8:24:00 PM

    It's not as simple as some of these readers seem to think. Maybe you're a Dallas native who grew up being told what to do as you learned to drive... I've lived in several states, and none has as confusing a toll system as Dallas. I have been trying to figure it out for months. I don't work or live north, so didn't figure I'd need a toll tag (only to visit friends in northwest Dallas on rare occasions). But I run into indications of toll roads with no obvious way to pay, and this is very confusing to me. I pay cash when there's a booth, of course, but so often there is neither a booth nor instructions. So I got a GPS and programmed it to keep me off toll roads (which are not always marked). For a month, I had license plates from my former state and wonder if the bills for unwitting infractions will go to my former address... and when the bills are going to come... this article has me even more concerned. The state is clearly exploiting the people, in this case.

  • Chris 02/03/2009 12:16:00 AM

    I try to avoid these double taxing tollroads at all costs. Tollroads should be banned in Texas. The NTTA is nothing but a bunch of idiotic morons, call them sometime if you need proof - all they care about, as an arm of the state, is money. They do not want to help you, or work with you. I spent almost an entire day on the phone with them over a $.30 toll and $25 fee because their readers did a misread on one booth - even though it picked up the other 5 booths on my tag as it should without issue - they were rude and all they did was threaten me instead of listening or trying to help me figure out a solution. Rude idiots.

  • Chris 02/03/2009 12:15:00 AM

    I try to avoid these double taxing tollroads at all costs. Tollroads should be banned in Texas. The NTTA is nothing but a bunch of idiotic morons, call them sometime if you need proof - all they care about, as an arm of the state, is money. They do not want to help you, or work with you. I spent almost an entire day on the phone with them over a $.30 toll and $25 fee because their readers did a misread on one booth - even though it picked up the other 5 booths on my tag as it should without issue - they were rude and all they did was threaten me instead of listening or trying to help me figure out a solution. Rude idiots.

  • Scott 01/24/2009 2:29:00 AM

    Here's a copy of a letter I sent to Channel 11 about the NTTA tactics. To: Mr. Bennett Cunningham Channel 11 News, Dallas Mr. Cunningham, I have seen you reports on many NTTA matters and thought you would be interested in my problem. I bought a car for my daughter and added her to my tolltag account. The car was registered in my name till it was paid off. During that time I removed her from my account and she obtained her own tolltag. She then started to run a negative balance on her account and, you know the rest, NTTA started sending ME the violation notices. I got involved and told them I was not reasonable for the tolls. They agreed that the car had a tolltag belonging to my daughter associated with the plate number on the car at the time the charges were incurred. They then informed me that due to Texas Transportation code 366.178 I would be held reasonable and that the matter would be turned over to collections, generate a citation, a fine and even subject me AND my wife to ARREST!! I told them to bring it on. I would LOVE to see them haul me and my wife off to jail for something WE did not do. I told them I would pay for the actual tolls, less fines, if they would acknowledge that this was not going to be a problem for ME again. They did and I paid the tolls. After a few months it started all over again. This time I called and told them we had been down this road before. That they had acknowledged these were not my tolls and I would not be bothered with this again. Of coarse again you know the rest. Now they don't know what I'm talking about and they are going forward with all the above mentioned actions. I have since paid the car off and transferred it into my daughters name to stop anymore of this nonsense but the above charges and threats still continue even though, once again, I made them an offer to pay the remaining tolls less fines. They refused to accept this offer and today (1/19/2009) I received a call from their collection agency. Now, I can't be the only person in Texas getting this treatment. These tactics seem unconstitutional to me. They are trying to hold me responsible for the actions of another even AFTER they acknowledged the car had a tolltag associated with it. This is absurd! Am I going to be held responsible if she robs a bank in my car? No, of coarse not, but these people have managed to get many things done here in Texas that are questionable. This is just another abusive action in a long list of the same from NTTA and it's time to put a stop to it all. I am willing to go as far as necessary to get this changed. 366.178 or not, this is just wrong. The rental car agencies are billing renters for speed pass charges incurred during the rental. Are these companies also being held responsible for the actions of others? I doubt it! That's a double standard if it's true. Today I called NTTA again to try and settle this with no luck. It then occured to me that the bill has my daughters account number on it. After pointing this out to them and even after telling them that she agrees the charges are hers they refused to remove me from the bill. See you in court NTTA.

  • Scott 01/24/2009 2:29:00 AM

    Here's a copy of a letter I sent to Channel 11 about the NTTA tactics. To: Mr. Bennett Cunningham Channel 11 News, Dallas Mr. Cunningham, I have seen you reports on many NTTA matters and thought you would be interested in my problem. I bought a car for my daughter and added her to my tolltag account. The car was registered in my name till it was paid off. During that time I removed her from my account and she obtained her own tolltag. She then started to run a negative balance on her account and, you know the rest, NTTA started sending ME the violation notices. I got involved and told them I was not reasonable for the tolls. They agreed that the car had a tolltag belonging to my daughter associated with the plate number on the car at the time the charges were incurred. They then informed me that due to Texas Transportation code 366.178 I would be held reasonable and that the matter would be turned over to collections, generate a citation, a fine and even subject me AND my wife to ARREST!! I told them to bring it on. I would LOVE to see them haul me and my wife off to jail for something WE did not do. I told them I would pay for the actual tolls, less fines, if they would acknowledge that this was not going to be a problem for ME again. They did and I paid the tolls. After a few months it started all over again. This time I called and told them we had been down this road before. That they had acknowledged these were not my tolls and I would not be bothered with this again. Of coarse again you know the rest. Now they don't know what I'm talking about and they are going forward with all the above mentioned actions. I have since paid the car off and transferred it into my daughters name to stop anymore of this nonsense but the above charges and threats still continue even though, once again, I made them an offer to pay the remaining tolls less fines. They refused to accept this offer and today (1/19/2009) I received a call from their collection agency. Now, I can't be the only person in Texas getting this treatment. These tactics seem unconstitutional to me. They are trying to hold me responsible for the actions of another even AFTER they acknowledged the car had a tolltag associated with it. This is absurd! Am I going to be held responsible if she robs a bank in my car? No, of coarse not, but these people have managed to get many things done here in Texas that are questionable. This is just another abusive action in a long list of the same from NTTA and it's time to put a stop to it all. I am willing to go as far as necessary to get this changed. 366.178 or not, this is just wrong. The rental car agencies are billing renters for speed pass charges incurred during the rental. Are these companies also being held responsible for the actions of others? I doubt it! That's a double standard if it's true. Today I called NTTA again to try and settle this with no luck. It then occured to me that the bill has my daughters account number on it. After pointing this out to them and even after telling them that she agrees the charges are hers they refused to remove me from the bill. See you in court NTTA.

  • Adam 01/21/2009 10:39:00 PM

    While I agree that the NTTA needs to get on top of their billing so that violators do not wrack up mulitple fees before being billed, I disagree that the toll booth vs lack of booth setup is confusing. It's pretty simple, when there are toll booths, each lane is labelled: Tolltag only, Exact Change, Change Made, etc. There is no "Bill Me Later" lane. Anyone with basic reading comprehension and a little common sense should be able to figure out that if they don't have a tolltag, don't take the lane labelled "TollTag Only" if there is a "Cash" lane right next to it. Unless of course you plan on just not paying and figure you can claim ignorance if that catches up with you.

  • Trey Garrison 01/21/2009 10:39:00 PM

    Screw 'em. Don't pay. What can they do?

  • Trey Garrison 01/21/2009 10:36:00 PM

    Screw 'em. Don't pay. What can they do?

  • John 01/21/2009 4:35:00 PM

    The officer in the story got off lucky, I was nailed for more than twice that, in 07. I'm looking forward to a very interesting phone call with the NTTA.

  • Steve 01/20/2009 4:54:00 PM

    I have had this exact problem using the North Dallas Tollway before. I moved here from Chicago a year and a half ago and was using a rental car to get to job interviews. In Chicago every tollbooth has a cash pay option if you dont have a toll tag. (or I pass as us yankees call it) I found that on the North/South tollway that not all the tolls had somewhere to pay. I was just charged 15 dollars by Alamo rent a car 2 weeks ago for the infraction in July 2007!! When I called the NTTA the person helping me said there was no where to cash pay on the particular toll that I violated and said he would call Alamo for me and call me back. Well that never happened and I was informed by Alamo that I should be getting a bill from the NTTA in a couple weeks to settle up on the toll with them. (which I still have not received) This is rediculous!! How are visitors in rental cars supposed to know when they can or can't pay a toll and what they should do about it. In Illinois they have signs after every toll that tell you who to call or what website to look up if you accidently blew the toll. Now whenever friends come to visit me I tell them stay off the tollway because you might get screwed. Not only is this a problem for Dallas residents but it is also a problem for tourists. (which Dallas has little of, there's a shocker huh?) My days of using the tollway are over.

  • tom 01/19/2009 9:25:00 PM

    as usual THEY GOT YOU ARGUING WITH EACH OTHER SO THAT YOU MISS THE POINT ( some of you)and DONT CATCH ON the government is draining us dry $25 fees??? They let people NOT pay literally hundreds of thousands of LEGITMATE tolls and then tag on arbitrary fees to support THEIR LACK OF EFFICIENCY But they get you areguing on who is right or wrong WE KNOW ITS WRONG TO NOT PAY THE TOLLS END OF THE STORY THE REAL STORY IS HOW WE HAVE BECOME SERVANTS OF THE STATE

  • Sam 01/19/2009 5:23:00 PM

    That nothing. I rarely drive the Toll roads; however I did have a Toll Tag that was tied to a Credit Card. After several years, I finally used up the pre-paid amount and NTTA tried to charge my now expired Credit Card. Unknown to me, I racked up $10 worth of toll charges and $1,300 in fees. But that nothing, they also sent it to Court where I was issued a Failure to Appear, even thought I was never notified about the appearance. I only learned about it when I was arrested during a traffic stop in Addison for a lane change. I spent 5 days in jail because the only phone numbers I knew were cell phones that can not be called from jail.

  • Juan 01/19/2009 3:44:00 PM

    This guy is crazy there are signs, he just need to read them.

  • Bobert 01/17/2009 1:18:00 AM

    If you wish to feel better about the toll road situation in Texas, go to Oklahoma and try a few. They still charge fees on roads that paid out decades ago. The roadways are just a notch better than when the sooner wagons were racing across the state. Cash booths may be on the left side at one location and on the right side at the next. Asking for amounts neeeded to reach a certain location results in a puzzled look only exceeded by asking for some extra quarters to feed future booths. If an attendant smiles and says thank you, an anvil drops out of the ceiling on top of his head.

  • Ravi 01/16/2009 10:21:00 PM

    I received a bill last week for $168! Thanks NTTA.

  • Tracy 01/16/2009 8:18:00 PM

    If you don't have a Tolltag sticker, you stop whenever there's a toll booth. Seems intuitive to me. And that simple rule works in every situation your article describes.

  • Lisa 01/16/2009 6:08:00 PM

    Did he think the cash toll booths were just little houses in the midst of a road? The lanes through which a vehicle can travel without stopping are clearly marked toll tag only lanes.

  • Tracy 01/16/2009 5:33:00 PM

    The toll booth protocols seem as simple as this: if there's a booth and you don't have a window tag, stop and pay. If there's no booth, you'll be billed only for actual tolls. Just common sense, seems to me. I rarely get on a toll road, but bought a sticker and loaded it only with $20, just to make sure I didn't have to have cash. There's no fee at all for the account, and it doesn't expire.

  • Jay Kimmerly 01/16/2009 4:12:00 PM

    Hey, Schutze, you moron! Tell 'em to move from Dallas County and the money they would save from the real estate tax for the "PARKLAND ILLEGAL MEXICAN BABY HOSPITAL" will easily pay your toll tag bill. Best regards, Jay Kimmerly Plano, Texas

  • JKR 01/15/2009 7:08:00 PM

    This is why it is better to stay in East Dallas. There is no reason to leave, really.

  • Roadside 01/15/2009 6:30:00 PM

    Well at least John actually drove on the Toll road. I got fine for over a 1000$ for toll road usage in Houston for Dec. 2006 to Feb 2007 and I had not even been to Houston for 6 years. Seems Enterprise Rent a Car decided I had rented a car from them and run some tolls. It had been over 3 years since I had rented a car from them. So they sent my name and my out of date address into a Houston court who sent me a fine and demanded I appear in court in Houston. After hours of phone tag, brush offs, and rude responses I finally found out I had to write a letter to the court and they would enter it into evidence at my trial. Appearently Enterprise could not come up with the documentation necessary to show I actually rented the car so the charges were dropped, but not without a bunch of waited time and elevated blood pressure.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy