Can teaching rebellious teenage girls how to become old-school "ladies" save them from a cycle of teen pregnancy and poverty?

Nyjai Hill is dressed like a debutante, but she isn't in the mood to act like one. Wearing a white dress, a tiara and gloves that reach her elbows, she can no longer ignore the pain in her feet as she balances on teetering heels. When she spots her mother in the hallway of the Hilton Anatole, Nyjai gathers the ends of her fluffy dress as if hauling a pile of laundry and heads toward her.

The young debutantes are introduced to the audience during the June 13 Junior Debutante Ball at the Hilton Anatole.
Sara Kerens
The young debutantes are introduced to the audience during the June 13 Junior Debutante Ball at the Hilton Anatole.
At a rehearsal two days before the big day, the girls learn an elaborate curtsy.
Sara Kerens
At a rehearsal two days before the big day, the girls learn an elaborate curtsy.

Details


Web Extra: Video from the PFWC debutante cotillion.

More photos from the cotillion and the Junior Debutante classes in this slideshow.

Related Content

More About

Nyjai's mother hands her a pair of flats, and, relieved, she slips them on and falls in line with the eight other seventh- to 11th-graders. The group grows quiet. Soon they will enter the ballroom and begin the three-hour ball.

It's June, and Nyjai (pronounced nigh-ja) is graduating from the Ladies by Design Junior Debutante Course, a program of the UrbanGirlz company, which is dedicated to building the self-esteem of black teens. Nyjai has spent the last 16 Saturdays at her church, Praise Fellowship Worship Center in Little Elm, learning how to embrace an old tradition once reserved for the white, wealthy elite.

She's a pretty 16-year-old with brown hair usually pulled into a loose bun and shoulders that tend to sag forward and pull her head down unless she remembers to stand up straight. A C- and D-student at Denton High School, she moved from a dangerous part of Cleveland, Ohio, with her mother and four younger siblings about four years ago. They bounced among several apartments here before settling in a three-bedroom house at the northern end of the Dallas North Tollway. (They'll be moving again soon since the bank foreclosed on the family's home last month.)

Born into a poor family -- a single mother raising five children, Nyjai appeared set to follow a common path to a predetermined end -- poverty, underemployment, early pregnancy and dropping out of school. She was getting into frequent fights and cussing people out. She sneaked out at night and had unprotected sex. But then her mother heard of the junior debutante program at Praise Fellowship Worship Center. After months of learning which fork to use, what kind of clothing is appropriate and how to rein in her attitude, Nyjai's grades have risen to A's and B's. And she has declared that she won't have sex again until she's married; God has a greater plan for her.

The odds are not in her favor. Born to a teen parent, Nyjai is statistically three times likelier than average to be a teen mother herself. Nationally, teen pregnancy is the single greatest factor in determining future poverty and homelessness for women and children. Taxpayers feel the burden too. Teen childbearing in Texas, as of 2004, cost taxpayers at least $1 billion, according to the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy.

At the ball, each girl has an escort -- their fathers, a church-assigned partner, or in Nyjai's case, a church minister, a young and personable man named Mel Johnson. "You're not even supposed to have your eyes looking at them," Johnson is telling Nyjai in the last minutes before the grand entrance, talking about texts between her and a boy from church. A ring he carries in his pocket to give Nyjai during the graduation is supposed to symbolize her promise to abstain from premarital sex.

Is she ready to commit?

"It's going to be hard, but I'm going to try not to have sex," Nyjai says, playfully worrying her minister.

"What do you mean you will try?" Johnson asks. "You're supposed to say you will not."

Nyjai sighs and stares at him. She brings her hand to her head to steady the slipping tiara.

"Yeeahhhh..." she says, rolling her eyes playfully.

Nyjai may still be cracking jokes with her minister up until the last minute, but he's clearly nervous about her future. The program is meant to change the lives of the teenage girls who go through it, and this evening may offer a first glimpse of whether it is working as intended.

----

The Ladies by Design Junior Debutante Course is part of a trend in programs springing up to help teens like Nyjai. Often promoted by churches or Boys and Girls Clubs as lessons in such things as hip-hop dance or engine building, the programs are in fact holistic youth development gigs. The goal is the same: Replace bad behavior by giving kids tools to make better decisions.

"A lot of times what they say they are is the hook to get the kids to come," says Amy Arbreton, who evaluates after-school programs across the country at Public/Private Ventures, a national nonprofit that creates and supports youth programs in low-income communities. In the last decade or so, there has been a shift from focusing on the specific problems, like teen pregnancy and dropping out of school, to developing the whole teenager. "Of course we need to reduce negative behaviors," Arbreton says, but "what are you trying to build in place of some of the issues the teen is having? How are you building a caring and responsible adult?"

For Trenette Wilson, creator of UrbanGirlz' Junior Debutante Program, building "proper ladies" is the way to reduce risky behavior, especially teen pregnancy. Wilson saw that abstinence education needed a boost beyond the nostrums of "just say no" and "true love waits." Low-income, inner-city girls at high risk of teen pregnancy also needed traditional social skills to help teach them self-respect.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next Page >>
 
  • ShanghaiJohnnyP 07/18/2009 6:57:00 AM

    I think if it works,it's a wonderful idea!!! Not saying I totally agree with the"Abstinence and Purity" Crowd,but I think if both young men and women agreed to not have sex until theyr'e adults it's great!!! However,here in the real world,today's kids need a"One From Column A"(Abstinence and Purity )and"Two From Column B"(Truthful Sex Education)approach!!! BTW,Sounds like Todd and Sarah Palin shoulda took Bristol to one of those!!!

  • Autumn Wilson 07/06/2009 7:26:00 PM

    I am glad to see a successful program being implemented into the mainstream society for those of us who would not have had an oppportunity to participate in a debutante ball if not for Urban Girlz. Thank you.

  • CaroJ 06/27/2009 5:57:00 PM

    Where's the corresponding program for boys? If you expect teenage girls to abstain from sex, you'd better have a similar program for the boys... complete with a ring asking them to pledge their bodies to God. This sounds sweet on the surface, but the underlying message is one of sexism. Girls give their bodies to God until they turn over their bodies to their new owners (husbands). Apparently, boys are still free to be boys....

  • TJ 06/26/2009 4:12:00 PM

    Having these girls pledge their bodies to "god" is fine and everything, but face it, abstinence rarely is reality. Why not encourage them to wait, but teach safe sex and birth control in case they "fall".

  • anon 06/25/2009 5:20:00 PM

    "But teaching proper manners to kids is a controversial approach in some academic circles. "Sometimes what is acceptable in the mainstream is not necessarily culturally appropriate," says Dr. David Chard, dean of SMU's Simmons School of Education and Human Development." Excuse me? Does this SMU Dean expect middle class behavior out of his students at SMU? Does he expect them to shake hands and greet people? Exactly why wouldn't he expect this behavior to be taught to children in poverty? Is this Dean confused over the mission of public education, or is he just stupid? If he has children, has he socialized them into the "culture of power" or the culture of those who are disempowered? Does Chard confuse understanding different subcultures with practices that keep people in the underclasses? What does he think the mission of public education is but to encourage a fluid class structure in the US?

  • Tim Covington 06/25/2009 4:50:00 PM

    I think this is a great idea, and it should also be implemented for young men. Good manners and self discipline are required to be successful in the USA. As to the scholars who say that teaching these behaviors emphasizes one culture over another, I have a few things to say. One, good manners used to be a part of the African American culture in the USA. But, some people started calling that degrading names. Also, not looking people in the eye was expected of minorities and the poor before the civil rights movement. When people try to denigrate teaching the disadvantaged the social and cultural skills to successful, I want to ask them why they are trying to hold these people back.

  • Corey 06/25/2009 4:07:00 PM

    That is truly amazing. God is in the blessing business. Way to go Trenette!

  • Susan 06/25/2009 3:03:00 AM

    It sounds like a wonderful program. I wish the public schools would implement. Girls could choose between this course or gym.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy