Civility is the Last Thing the DISD Board Needs

The cabal that has always controlled the Dallas school district—and that includes the editorial page of The Dallas Morning News—doesn't even know what hit it in the recent school board election. I do. One word.

Newly elected Dallas school board member Bruce Parrott promises that he will not do what The Dallas Morning News has told him to do. He will not stay quiet; he will not do as he is told; and he will not be a good little boy.
Mark Graham
Newly elected Dallas school board member Bruce Parrott promises that he will not do what The Dallas Morning News has told him to do. He will not stay quiet; he will not do as he is told; and he will not be a good little boy.

Labor.

The teachers unions, traditionally fractured and at odds with each other, banded together very late in the day for this off-cycle election and fought for three candidates, two of whom won. In the long view of school board history here, that's pretty close to a revolution.

I will explain later how it happened. But first, I can't help myself. I just have to stop and marvel at the reaction of the Morning News editorial page.

Two days after the election, the paper ran an editorial warning the newly elected school board members that they had better shape up, toe the line and help the board keep on doing exactly what it's been doing.

Help me. I need to understand why the editorial page of the city's only daily newspaper would want this school board to keep doing what it's been doing.

In a little over a year the Dallas school system has made the single biggest budgeting mistake in its history. Then it clumsily hacked hundreds of teachers from the rolls to make up for it. The school system practically destroyed its own IT system in a purchasing scandal that has already sent one high-flying top official to the big house for 11 years.

The board refused to impose conflict-of-interest rules to prevent its own board president from doing millions of dollars a year in construction and repair business with the district. The board invented a phony-baloney legal argument to justify savaging faculties at its own very best schools, the magnets. And what else? Wasn't there something else?

Oh, yeah. The Third World banana republic thing. With all of these issues on the table and a punishing school board election coming up, the Dallas school board tried to suspend its own elections. It yielded only when the Texas attorney general told the board that elected officials cannot legally suspend their own elections in Dallas. In Texas, actually. Well, really, in America. Other countries, maybe. But it's definitely not a U.S. of A. thing to do.

Who knew?

Apparently the voters did. In the December 8 election, which the board was forced to hold against its will, incumbent trustee Leigh Ann Ellis repeatedly told crowds that she had voted to suspend the elections in order to save money on elections. She was defeated. It's called the old heave-ho—a tradition as ancient and revered as barrels of tea in Boston Harbor.

So two days after the election, the Morning News editorial page wags its inky finger at Bruce Parrott, the candidate whom the voters chose over Ellis, warning him that he had better not be "combative and unproductive" the way his wife, Lois Parrott, was when she was president of the school board four years ago.

"The district doesn't need another combative board to further complicate already difficult tasks," the editorial said.

It doesn't?

That's like saying it would have been "combative and unproductive" for somebody in the wheel house that fateful night, almost 98 years ago now, to have told the captain of the Titanic, "I think possibly we should perhaps turn the boat, maybe, sir."

Combative? Could be. But unproductive? No way.

The productive thing is not to hit icebergs, which the Dallas school board seems to do on some kind of dreadful regular rotation, like they're out there actively hunting for them. What could be better or healthier for the Dallas Independent School District than new board members who will ask tough and even combative questions?

It's not that there are no such persons now on the board. Trustee Carla Ranger, who represents District 6 in southwest Dallas near suburban Duncanville, has shown incredible, indomitable courage in confronting the oligarchy on school issues, even when they went after her source of personal livelihood.

Board president Adam Medrano, who represents District 8 in northwest Dallas all the way up to the intersection of the LBJ and Stemmons Freeways, is less outspoken than Ranger but nevertheless has shown real independence.

Lew Blackburn, who represents District 5 in south central Dallas down to the suburbs of Hutchins and Lancaster, sometimes can be a shrewd and effective opponent of the controlling gang. But that does raise a question. Who is the gang?

I spoke last week with David Bradley, an activist in the Democratic Party for 25 years and one of the architects of the election strategy that took two key seats away from the establishment in the recent election. He told me he views the controlling gang as a group of powerful entities and persons who have traditionally made money doing business with the district.

"The biggest problem I think with the DISD," he says, "is the fact that what I refer to as the oligarchy—you may call them the establishment or whatever the hell you want to call them—view the school district as a revenue opportunity."

The fact that they make money off the district—in school construction, legal fees, banking and consulting—gives this group a powerful incentive to maintain control.

1 | 2 | Next Page >>
 
  • Alfredo's Leigh Ann'O Joke'O 12/20/2009 7:09:00 AM

    I liked joke where Ellis' old buddy Alfredo comes back and tells Leigh Ann "You got what you asked for, right? Gave away all those pansies on election day for nothing!"

  • James Dunn 12/19/2009 6:54:00 PM

    As I was driving my new Porsche Panamera down Inwood Road headed north from the dealership located on Lemmon Ave., I got to the crossroads of Inwood and Northwest Hwy. On that corner, the IDIOTOMETER started to emit a faint hum. As I got close to Park Ln., the hum grew much louder. On the corner of Walnut Hill and Inwood, the sound was deafening. Over the din, my boyfriend asked, "What the hell is that?" I told him that it was the new Porsche Idiotometer. When it approaches a supreme idiot, it makes a loud sound. "Look," I said. "The GPS is about to speak." When the GPS spoke, it said that we were in a BUSHIT area. "What does that mean?" my boyfriend asked, eyes wide with fright. "It means that we are near BUSHIT," I said. "Kinda like lies but much worse. Bushit is lies mixed with squandering fiscal responsibility, sending 5,000 soldiers to die for a false cause and ignoring the needs of the poor even when they are drowning atop the roofs their own houses. It means always kowtowing to a wealthy establishment to make them, and yourself, wealthier." "Caution" the GPS screamed, "Beware of GeorgeWasaurus. It's full of BUSHIT." "Where are we?" "We're on Daria Drive. Right in front of the home of George W, the most dangerous BUSHITTER that has ever romed the earth. He bankrupted the WORLD! His father once bankrupted the United States and his nephew is poised to one day bankrupt the universe!! In Spanish!!' I said when the Idiotometer was making the car thump like a rap lovers car in the bad part of town. We zoomed toward White Rock GPS and Idiotometer still blasting. When we pulled up in front of the Bruce Parrott home, the idiotometer suddenly went off and the GPS started to play the old gospel song, "Free at Last." Soon the voice of Martin Luther King Jr. started to say the, "I Have a Dream" speach. "Are we safe yet?" the love of my life asked. "Maybe," I replied. "We've got Barak. We've got Bruce. Maybe just towing the line on an ever sinking ship is going to go away." Just then the SYCOPHANTOMETER alerted that there were no sycophants around. "Maybe there is hope after all"

  • Abbie 12/17/2009 10:21:00 PM

    Jim, I understand the exasperation of anyone regarding the Dallas ISD or any of its governing parts. It makes sense that readers of the DMN�s editorial might be angry, even alarmed that high-profile columnists would insist on maintaining the current way of doing business. But I believe that we could have a school board full of revolutionaries�Gandhi himself could act as Board President�who would still have a helluva time curbing dropout rates. Dallas is a a typical urban school district, which unfortunately means that there are fundamental, chronic, depressing issues at play�from the staggering amount of disadvantaged students (About 87%), to an unimaginable amount of English Language Learners. The problems facing the Dallas ISD and the city as a whole are�.I can�t find the appropriate adjective...limitless? Epic? Tragic? Meh, none of them seem to describe the problem adequately. Yes, we absolutely need movers and shakers on the school board who are willing to undertake a drastic and dramatic upheaval of the status quo. But more importantly, and I really hate to invoke this tired image, we need the entire village�from the federal government on down, to get behind our students. We need more volunteers, good teachers in failing schools, food for hungry students, medical checkups, more afterschool programs, better ELL classes, more accurate ways to measure student achievement, parent involvement, faith-based involvement, tutors, mentors, money� An effective school board is a start, but getting up and arms about the DMN editorial seems odd�or small, rather. The school board is just the regulator of the circus. They can say where the elephants need to piddle or what the performers need to wear, but it is what it is. They can only do so much. Sometimes asking probing questions and stirring up the biggest shit storm in the history of shit storms just means that there�s shit all over a shitty situation.

  • Bruce = Kick-Ass @ the DISD 12/17/2009 8:02:00 PM

    Guess the general public knows who is primed to kick-ass @ the DISD. The Dallas Morning News - Dallas ISD Blog: Who should be the next DISD board president? 2:19 PM Mon, Dec 14, 2009 | Permalink Tawnell Hobbs/Reporter At this Thursday's meeting, the two trustee-elects � Bernadette Nutall and Bruce Parrott � will be sworn in. And afterwards, the board will elect board officers. Word is that trustee Adam Medrano will likely remain in the president spot, but who knows until the votes go down. Who would be board president if you had your way? Take our poll below. MicroPoll Who should be the next DISD board president? Nancy Bingham 0%4 Lew Blackburn 2%35 Edwin Flores 1%13 Jerome Garza 0%3 Jack Lowe 8%149 Adam Medrano 2%38 Bernadette Nutall 0%6 Bruce Parrott 69%1301 Carla Ranger 18%337 Total Votes : 1886

  • Martha 12/17/2009 7:53:00 PM

    Well, this is deja vue all over again. I was student teaching at J F Kimball in the spring of 1968. There was another upstart group trying to oust the powers that were. It was called "The Committee For Good Schools". Principal Bill Durrett at Kimball told his faculty the day before the election that these folks were a genuine threat to DISD and if they won, the staff might likely loose their jobs. CGS did win and then superintendent W. T. White resigned, though I don't know if it had anything to do with the election results. I also don't know if much changed. I started teaching at Thomas Jefferson the next fall and I don't remember a lot of furor over new policies. But we hired Nolan Estes as superintendent and we know where that went. Oh well, I guess Dallas gets the schools it is willing to settle for. As the article stated, parent anger tends to be all sound and fury, signifying nothing and changing less.

  • FacePalm 12/17/2009 7:38:00 PM

    I'm getting tired of the euphemisms being used for the corrupt businessmen in "the oligarchy" or "the cabal". Start naming names, businesses, contracts, and where the money is going. These people are crooks. Stop helping them hide.

  • ajw 12/17/2009 4:51:00 PM

    A decline in the dropout rate is always welcome, but 43% is still abysmal. The school board's job is to make sure things run smoothly so that students can succeed. DISD is not and has not been in that business for decades. Hence the flight to Plano, Richardson, Coppell, Flower Mound... But when no one's minding the store, why not rob it? Let's suspend elections and build us some schools instead of maintaining the ones we already have, buying books or paying teachers!

  • Cliffhanger 12/17/2009 3:59:00 PM

    This brushfire isn't going to die down. Last year's RIFs and the Title 1 fiasco just flat pissed me off. I'm mad, and I'm still going to be mad when the elections roll around in 2010. I'll be doing everything I can to elect a candidate who will actually work for teachers and my two kids during the next election cycle, when I get a chance to throw some more of the bums out.

  • 12/17/2009 4:13:00 AM

    Jim, You write in relatively negative terms about DISD. While an organization that large would certainly have many negative things happening, their goal is to educate our children. In that area I must argue that DISD is making some progress. My own fixation is our dropout rate. The Graduation Class of 2008 only graduated with 41% of the class they originally had in the 9th grade. However, DISD is getting better. The Class of 2009 had a 43.5% graduation rate. It is projected that the Class of 2010 will achieve a graduation rate that will be a 6 year record! Records will continue to be set for the next several years as the 9th grade enrollment has dropped significantly due to fewer students failing 9th grade. I'll be speaking on an agenda item, the new DISD public information web site being planned and reported on by the Policy Briefing Chair, Dr. Flores. It will not be voted on till January. I will be outlining some qualities that the multi-year enrollment by grade spreadsheet they plan to place on that web site should have. I'll be handing out the first 4 pages from http://www.studentmotivation.org/DallasISD.htm web pages to illustrate the value of such transparency. The graph on that fourth page gives a good idea of the tremendous progress DISD has made in the past 4 years using four separate measurements for dropout rates. I welcome your critical reading. I'm certain you agree that true transparency is the best weapon we have to improve our school district. Right now that transparency shows that our graduation rate is heading the right direction - UP! Will you be at the meeting? I'll hand out copies of those 4 pages to the board for my three minute talk on their value.

  • Michael123 12/17/2009 3:13:00 AM

    Go Bruce! You took some sleeze-ball political hits from Leigh Ann and her wannabe journalist Gwinn but you kicked ass anyway. Hinojosa Must Go! Ellis is gone and Price in gone, that is great!

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy