By Jim Schutze
By Rachel Watts
By Lauren Drewes Daniels
By Anna Merlan
By Lee Escobedo
By Alice Laussade
By Scott Reitz
Even those people who follow pop music on a cursory basis were probably familiar with Winehouse, or at least her troubles; dubbed (almost too easily) "Wino" by the tabloids both in her homeland and around the world, she was a mainstay on the gossip pages for her problems with alcohol and drugs and her ex-husband Blake Fielder-Civil, not to mention her signature beehive-and-cat's-eye look. But her talent was prodigious as both a singer and a songwriter; she wrote or co-wrote all the songs on her stunning breakthrough Back To Black, an album that she was still working on following up.
When she was on, Winehouse had few peers — she wasn't an octave-jumper like other big divas of the moment, but her contralto had a snap to it that enriched even the simplest syllables with a full spectrum of emotion. Back To Black was filled with aching songs like "Love Is A Losing Game" and "You Know That I'm No Good" that chronicled mutually detrimental relationships and the people who stayed in them, for whatever reasons they had. And that she could speak of such pain with a fair amount of lyrical wit is a testament to her talent, which was nurtured at the BRIT School and which resulted in her debut album Frank coming out when she was only 20 years old.
Many in the online peanut gallery are saying that her death was "inevitable" — that the gamut of her gossip-page-worthy problems, which she nodded to in her Top 10 hit "Rehab" as well as in other tracks, was going to result in sadness no matter what.
She had already had enough tragedy befall her that it's hard not to wonder if this particular closing chapter wasn't preventable somehow. Her handlers rushed her back to the stage when she clearly wasn't ready a month ago in Serbia and earlier in other far-flung locales where people would point and click and snicker at her woes as they were brought into the public eye. Perhaps the point-and-gawk cycle was just too powerful.
A February 2007 piece in the Washington Post, written after her Stateside debut at Joe's Pub in New York and right before Black came out over here, implied that her real-life problems would be a way to help her get her noticed by online outlets that didn't specialize in music, particularly the gossip sites that were ascendant (and definitely outdrawing music-centric sites) back then; the idea that this would be what set her apart from the pack, rather than her talent as a singer and a songwriter, was loathsome then, but it's just tragic now.
Especially so, considering the singer's lukewarm feelings toward fame. A quote from Winehouse in that Post article: "I don't give a [expletive]. I know it's good for the record company if I do well here. I don't care. If I had my choice, I'd be a roller-skating waitress in the middle of nowhere, singing songs to my husband while I'm cooking grits somewhere. What I'm doing I'm so grateful to be doing — it's so exciting, so fun. But I've never been the kind of girl who knocks on someone's door and says, 'Make me famous.'"
She was 27.