Prosecutors team with debt collectors to terrorize consumers in ways both highly profitable and usually illegal.

By that point, she was so deep in debt that she filed for bankruptcy. Only after she consulted an attorney did she discover that it wasn't the DA sending her all those letters. It was an Arkansas company called District Attorney Technical Services. "The real district attorney had not investigated me or considered filing charges against me."

Meanwhile, the letters kept coming, threatening her with arrest. She eventually became part of a class-action lawsuit filed by Arons against the company's owner, Henry Craighead.7

The suit claimed that District Attorney Technical Services illegally disguised itself as a government entity in order to extort penalties and fees. In 2011, a federal court awarded 36,000 victims nearly $750,000 in damages.

Julie Orr bounced a $91 check at a grocery store, but was hounded for more than $300 by a private collections agency.
Rodrigo Pena
Julie Orr bounced a $91 check at a grocery store, but was hounded for more than $300 by a private collections agency.
Adam Levin, former consumer affairs commissioner of New Jersey and owner of
Adam Levin, former consumer affairs commissioner of New Jersey and owner of

But it was too late. That same year, Craighead declared bankruptcy himself and only paid $160,000. He's now retired and living comfortably in Oregon, says Arons.

"That's what they do," Arons says. "Whenever we win one of these cases, they declare bankruptcy in order to avoid paying out damages. It's absolutely maddening."

The exact same thing had happened a year earlier, when Arons won a similar suit against American Corrective Counseling Services. A federal court ruled that, despite the company's claims of immunity, it had misrepresented itself, made false threats of prosecution and charged exorbitant penalties.

Once again, Arons' clients were unable to collect on their victory. American Corrective also declared bankruptcy, saying it couldn't repay investors — despite having herded $47 million in fees over the previous four years.

A few months later it was back in business, re-formed as Corrective Solutions and "free and clear" of all liability, according to court records.

Today it's the biggest bad-check collector of them all.

A Payday for Prosecutors

Mike Wilhelms is president and CEO of Corrective Solutions. His LinkedIn profile boasts a photo of a fresh-faced surfer boy in charge of more than 200 employees. The California counties of Los Angeles, San Bernardino, Riverside and Orange are his biggest customers, all within driving distance of his palm-tree-lined headquarters in San Clemente, where it's clear that business is booming.

Consumer-rights lawyers estimate the company sends out around 2 million letters annually. (The company did not respond to repeated interview requests.)

The Corrective Solutions website does its best to imply that it's an arm of law enforcement. A slideshow gently fades in and out with statements about "holding offenders accountable for their actions." An interactive map shows its 140 contracts with DAs nationwide.

Nowhere does it say that most of these "offenders" have never been investigated or formally charged with a crime.

The site boasts dozens of quotes from pleased prosecutors, who sing praises of reduced caseloads and crime rates. Yet Contra Costa District Attorney Robert Kochly offers the most telling endorsement, noting he's grateful for "more revenue to my office."

District attorneys don't pay a cent for Corrective Solutions' services. Instead, the company pays them to run their bad-check programs. All a prosecutor must do is hand over official letterhead, along with a list of bad-check writers and a bit of "case criteria."

Between 2005 and 2008, Los Angeles County raked in more than $1 million. Miami-Dade made over $375,000.

When asked whether Miami-Dade's program was little more than a moneymaking scheme, Toussaint balks.

"Diverting such cases out of the criminal justice system gives an individual with no prior record an opportunity to avoid having a criminal record," she says. "It makes the victim receiver of the worthless check whole, and it is done with no cost to the taxpaying citizens of our community. Pre-trial diversion programs also allow the courts to focus on other types of criminal activity."

But while prosecutors claim they use collection agencies to decrease caseloads, some companies actually promise to expand them — for the sole purpose of generating more money.

Take BounceBack, the industry's second-largest player. It owns Check Connection, and makes no bones that generating fees is mission one.

"Is your program suffering from diminishing checks?" asks the company's website. "Visit Check Connection to learn how you can substantially increase the number of checks in your bad check program."

The site offers examples from places like Palm Beach County, Florida, which switched to BounceBack in 2006 after "merchants and other victims were complaining that they felt intimidated by the people administering the program. Check writers complained of strong-arm collection tactics."

Since then, Palm Beach has "passed the $1.5 million mark."

BounceBack won't discuss its business practices, believing it's been unfairly vilified by the media. "The press usually doesn't take anything that we say seriously, so we've begun to decline to make comments," says company vice president Gale Krieg.

Still, prosecutors eagerly rise to the industry's defense.

"They're not just some debt-collection company," Louis Alvarez, head of the Los Angeles DA's check program, says of Corrective Solutions. "What they are doing is trying to help us recoup money for victims."

The real victims, at least in Alvarez's mind, aren't math-challenged consumers, but merchants who lose more than $120 billion annually to bad checks, according to the Federal Reserve. He argues that Corrective Solutions is simply helping his overburdened and underfunded office get restitution — while "rehabilitating" check writers who are likely guilty of fraud.

« Previous Page
Next Page »
My Voice Nation Help
scottindallas topcommenter

So, Is Unfair Park dead?  Maybe it's my browser, but this thing seems all screwy.  

Anyway, this goes to my point about utilities, they are distinct markets from free markets, and privateering in them can be quite pernicious.  Gov't need to do what it do, and stay out of truly free markets, and concern itself only with crimes against people. 


If you think this is bad, you should talk to individuals in Texas who've been convicted of a minor drug offense, a DWI, or DUI. Ankle monitor companies, Interlock devices, specialty courts, special counseling groups, none of it optional. Refusal means the offender goes to jail. It is a big money business for both private enterprise and city-county-state government (you KNOW they are making a little money somewhere or they wouldn't hook up with these scheisters). Some offenders are on the hook to the county or the state for thousands of dollars every month--no wonder recidivism is so high. And if you fail to keep up this high debt, probation is revoked and you go to a privatized prison where there is no motivation to get you out and back into society. You're worth more to the state of Texas as a prisoner than a tax-paying citizen! It is a national disgrace! If people only knew the stories of these poor souls who had one lapse in judgement and the consequences and repercussions are enormous.


How insane is it that our so-called representatives allow this to go on? They should burn this whole sham industry to the ground. The companies who push those red-light cameras have the same agenda. They can talk about public safety all they want, but everyone knows it's all about the Benjamins.


It's time to hold our district attorney's responsible for their actions. This type of behavior should be unconscionable but it's not. It's perfectly legal and acceptable. Everyone's on the take here. Let me be more frank - even if they're not taking payoffs from the debt collection industry their election campaigns take contributions - whether straw or direct - and these can then, in some cases, be cash in the pocket of the elected official. Shame on them.


the only two Orr's I care about is Ben Orr, the great, departed bassist of The Cars, and the GREAT Bobby Orr-#4, the man who scored 146 points, AS A DEFENSEMEN. The best two way player ever!

TheCredibleHulk topcommenter

Interesting article.

I think I'll go check my checking acct. balance...