Ten-year-old Arnav Dhawa's Autopsy Done While Police Sat on His Medical Records

Ten-year-old Arnav Dhawa's Autopsy Done While Police Sat on His Medical Records
Daniel Fishel

You probably have passing familiarity with the boy-in-the-bathtub story, about 10-year-old Arnav Dhawan, the Frisco child whose decomposing, five-days-dead body was found by police under ice packs in the family bathtub. The mother, 38-year-old Pallavi Dhawan, is charged with murder, even though the official finding on cause of death in the final autopsy report was, "Natural disease is most likely."

At some point soon her case will be taken before a grand jury. The findings of the autopsy also left open "the possibility of an unnatural cause of death."

But would that door still be open at all if the assistant medical examiner who did the autopsy had been provided the boy's full medical history before the autopsy was performed?

On the night of January 29, police were called to the Dhawans' comfortable suburban home by the father, who had just returned from a long business trip to find his son missing. Only after police arrived did they and the father discover the boy lying dead in a bathtub.

Police say they asked the mother at that point if she killed her son. They say she nodded yes. Early on in the case, family and friends suggested to reporters that in India people sometimes nod yes when they mean no. Either way, it seems like a strangely vague answer to an awfully important question.

Pallavi Dhawan's lawyer, David Finn, says the head-nod conversation seems odd because it never took place. Finn is a former trial judge, former federal prosecutor and former Tarrant County assistant district attorney.

"That conversation didn't happen," he said. "I drilled down hard on her. I drilled down hard on the husband, who was standing right next to her.

"Here's what really happened. The husband and wife were sitting there. The husband asked the wife privately but kind of close to the police, 'Where's Arnav?' And she said, 'He is no more.' Which is their way of saying he's dead.

"And the husband goes, 'What?' And the wife said, 'He is no more.' So the husband looks to the police and is about to cry, and they can see something is going on. And they ask both of them, 'Is he in there [the closed bathroom]?' And, 'Yes.' And here's the second question: 'Is he alive?' Those are the only two questions they asked my girl. Because the minute they kicked the door in, they called for the paramedics.

"He wasn't declared dead for an hour. But the minute they found him in the bathroom, they separated the husband and the wife about 10 feet apart. They told the wife, 'Turn around, you're under arrest.' They cuffed her. They put her in the squad car. And then about 45 minutes later they Mirandized her.

"But this, 'Did you kill him?' That question was never posed to her."

The police say they did ask her if she killed her son and she did nod yes. Finn says they did not ask and she did not nod, yes or no. At this point we might put most of this away as sort of a he-said she-said dispute between the police and an aggressive defense lawyer. But there is a second important point of divergence between Finn's account of things and the police version.

Arnav Dhawan was born with serious medical conditions diagnosed early in life by physicians at the University of Wisconsin and at the Mayo Clinic. He suffered from a brain cyst and a condition that caused him to have a smaller than normal skull. Children with these conditions typically lead short lives and may present behavioral issues.

Arnav was a cheerful child who for some years was able to live a more normal life than many with his conditions. But in recent years something changed. The change was enough to cause his mother to quit her professional career in order to take care of him full-time at home. The father traveled to support the family, often abroad.

The final report of the Collin County medical examiner ticks down a list of possible indications of foul play and finds none present. Then it presents a series of conditions found in the body that could have led to death, all consonant with the boy's long-term medical problems. So why wasn't the report more definitive about assigning death to natural causes?

When the assistant medical examiner was carrying out the autopsy, none of the boy's medical history had been made available to her. Dr. Lynn A. Salzberger, assistant Collin County medical examiner, states in her report: "No medical history was revealed until two days after the autopsy was performed."

Salzberger told me, "That information was not revealed at all to us or to anyone in my office. The only information we got in this case was that this child was ADD, which ironically is the one diagnosis that this kid does not have that I could find in his medical records. That was it. That was basically all that we were told was wrong with this child, period, when the autopsy was performed."

I asked how she finally learned there was a history to look for.

1
 
2
 
All
 
Next Page »
 
My Voice Nation Help
8 comments
lebowski300
lebowski300

What doesn't make sense to me is why the father calls the police and never talks to his wife, who is right there. So something very odd indeed.

dfwenigma
dfwenigma

What a rather obviously botched case. Total joke. I can't believe the DA would even take this to a grand jury. Really? Tainted evidence. Possibly fruit of the poisonous tree. This whole thing goes from bad to worse. But then it's typical Collin and Dallas County. Typical dodge and perry. And what happens is pretty predictable. It's usually a good 'ole boys and girls club. The DA becomes a judge, the retiring DA or judge becomes a criminal defense attorney, then the retiring judge or criminal defense attorney, a former DA gets a nod on a federal appointment of some kind - and on it goes. Some of them actually become federal judges. And people wonder why I'm four-square against the death penalty and why I personally concur with people who say that our prisons are still filled with people who are mentally ill and in general the throw-aways of society. It's not because some aren't just plain murderous scum, it's just that it looks far tougher, far more right-wing pandering, Tea Party affirming Republican to spend lots of money, outsource jails and the like than it does to whittle down our list of inmates to those that are truly violent and unrepetent versus those are completely bonkers. We don't have a way of caring for the seriously mentally ill. This woman may have been guilty of something but more than likely she's guilty of very simply being unable to cope with a really bad situation. You want guilt for the death of the boy America - Collin and Dallas County residents - look in the mirror. And every time you don't vote or vote for idiots who are one notch up on the conservative belt - remember - these are the people that vote against mental health funding, these are the guys who vote for larger, "tougher" jails and people who like to bury their heads in the sand rather than find real solutions to difficult problems.

sunnil53
sunnil53

If the police cannot prove homicide as the cause of death beyond a reasonable doubt, no competent  jury will convict the mother of murder or manslaughter. Clearly, she is entitled to the benefit of the doubt.

sugarbush43
sugarbush43

This story gets me so angry.  The Frisco PD is clearly inept, what with all the stories I've read of them in the news as of late.  They don't seem to have any clue as to what they're doing, what laws to enforce, or how to enforce them.  It's truly pathetic.  


The ME noted previously that it seems likely that the cause of death was natural, due to his seizure condition.  Mrs. Dhawan has gone into detail publicly and privately about what happened and it all seems extremely plausible.  A mother who wakes up to find her young, beloved child dead is going to go through major denial issues and not act "normal".  No mother can be in her "right mind" at a time like that.  And she said that she didn't call the police or ambulance, because she knew they would take his body from her.  I can sympathize with that, as a mother.  


Instead of being reasonable and thinking before they acted, the Frisco PD jumped to conclusions and seemingly felt like it was finally their shot as being in their very own episode of Law & Order.  To charge this woman and seek indictment with zero evidence other than a head gesture and an "undetermined cause of death" to "prove" she killed her son is insane.  


Frisco PD clearly needs new, competent leadership and a lot of training.

mcdallas
mcdallas

Too bad the family didn't have a cultural advocate to step in early.  "Lost in translation" seems to apply here both ways.

paulpsycho78
paulpsycho78

@dfwenigma The US has the highest incarceration rate in the whole world with 741 persons per 100,000...second Russia with 564 per 100,000...land of the free indeed

paulpsycho78
paulpsycho78

unless you have access to 15 grand you can kiss your ass goodbye.  this is a police state..we have the highest rate of incarceration in the entire world by far...over 700 persons per 100,000

 
Dallas Concert Tickets
Loading...