Like countless European-American filmmakers before him, African-American filmmaker John Singleton tends to operate under the faulty logic that vengeance equals heroism. Anyone who doubts this assertion is welcome to compare his grooveless, mean-spirited remake of Shaft to the deceptively simple and human original. This isn't to say that he's not an important filmmaker and a man of vision--in a decade of ambitious films, he's proven himself to be both. Nonetheless, that ugly, reactionary chip on his shoulder keeps tainting his otherwise impressive work. For example, in his latest feature, Baby Boy, he candy coats his sadistic kicks by attributing them not to his lead but to a clutch of expendable auxiliary characters, only one of whom wrestles himself free from the director's hammerlock of cartoonish rage and cheap redemption. The aftertaste is decidedly iffy.
This glitch is unfortunate, because in most other ways Baby Boy is the smartest and most sensitive movie in Singleton's blazing cannon. A cut-and-paste pastiche of material lifted wholesale from his Boyz N the Hood and Poetic Justice (joining them as the third installment of what he calls--egad--his "hood trilogy"), this feature embarks upon new frontiers within his beloved South-Central. The boyz are still here, and they're still bangin' and all...er...dat, but the director's ripening sensibilities are proving fruitful in unexpected ways. With the possible exception of his overwrought but well-intentioned Rosewood, Baby Boy is Singleton's first project to present itself not just as a black movie, but as a truly American movie, revealing our unique domestic screwups.
Our focal point here is Jody (Tyrese Gibson), whom we first encounter fully grown yet fetal, naked within the confines of a massive, watery womb. The symbolism isn't the most subtle (nor is it intended to be), but the message works, as we are informed that the black man has been made to think of himself as a baby, calling his woman "Mama," his friends "boys" and his home a "crib." While the underlying theme of black manhood isn't so different from that of Gary Hardwick's The Brothers earlier this year, the inescapable gravity of the hood--in which drink and jail vie with death for young men's souls--sets this project on its own distinctive turf.
To put it mildly, Jody has problems. Streetwise but jobless and directionless, he exists in a state of suburban complacency with his young single mother, Juanita (A.J. Johnson). He's only 20 years old, but already he's sired two kids with different women ("That's something I know how to do is make some pretty babies," he explains, by way of a résumé), and the juggling act is fast becoming a circus. While he makes clandestine visits to Peanut (Tamara Bass) and his baby daughter, Lil' Nut (Cleopatra Singleton), he also conjures the illusion that he's true to his main squeeze, Yvette (Taraji P. Henson), the mother of his toddler son, Joe Joe.
While Ice Cube had time to "philosophisize on God, church, bitches 'n' all" in Boyz, and Maya Angelou added depth to Justice, Jody affords himself no such spiritual luxuries, guided as he is by the little fella with the big attitude. Singleton makes assorted nods to (and swipes at) the "African booty-scratchers" of his first film, but here he's much more concerned with countless booty calls, following the horny but emotionally inept lad through assorted conquests, near misses and narrow escapes. The movie's outlandish candor and sex-play may not be for everyone, but it all feels refreshingly real, especially when anger and ardor intertwine. Happily, not only are the actors truly game for the ride, the cutting by Bruce Cannon reaches an awesome orgasmic fervor.
Of course, when sex rears its head, there are going to be issues, and Jody finds himself stuck between rocking and a very hard place when his mother's new boyfriend, Melvin (Ving Rhames), comes to call (or vice versa). A scarcely reformed gangster who gladly distracts Juanita from her zealous gardening, Melvin is the nightmare Jody has been dreading: a thug with insatiable hots for Mama, just like the previous one who wooed Juanita and convinced her to kick Jody's brother out of the nest and into the grave. While Jody struggles to chart a masculine course, he suddenly finds himself saddled with a violent bastard as potential role model. Cruel, cruel fate.
Even though Singleton throws in a few of his characteristic caricatures for cheap laughs or gasps (a fag hairdresser here, a megaslut there), Baby Boy adeptly delivers his most intricate and delicate relationships to date. It's a kick when Juanita explains to her son that she needs a man who can handle her, and, unnervingly, it's not too far removed from Yvette screeching to Jody, "I love Daddy's dick!" before kicking him out for his trespasses, then sheepishly admitting, "I miss his ass like shit." Woe to the English language, but the sentiments ring true.
Above all, this is a movie about fatherhood and commitment, and while Jody's gradual acquiescence to Melvin's bludgeoning presence (and culinary nudity) stretches credibility far beyond its elastic limit, Singleton's doses of sap--exacerbated by the heavy-handed guide track of composer David Arnold--are not lethal. It's a feel-good movie that happens to have a lot of feel-bad in it. The gratuitous violence sucks, and the pat conclusion prompts one to shout don't believe the hope!, but otherwise Singleton has wrangled his characters into a very impressive emotional exorcism.
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.