Boys and Twirls
The setting of Stephen Daldry's uplifting comedy Billy Elliot, about a working-class boy who wants to be a ballet dancer, is a beleaguered coal-mining town in the north of England, circa 1984. A coat of grime covers the squat brick-row houses, drying laundry flaps sadly in the breeze, and the locals all have the fierce-but-downtrodden look we've seen on the faces of British blue-collar blokes since John Osborne first looked back in anger. That's because the miners are on strike, money is short, and the edgy police are ready to break some union heads. We can feel defeat and danger in the air. This is hardly the place--or the time--for an 11-year-old to get his macho father and glowering older brother all lathered up over the notion of his becoming the next Rudolf Nureyev.
It is precisely the time and place, however, for him to succeed. For someone to succeed.
If, to regular moviegoers, this plot line sounds vaguely familiar, it should. In the underrated Brassed Off (1998), striking English miners took solace in their town's amateur brass band; in the far-more-popular The Full Monty, out-of-work Brits lifted their spirits by reinventing themselves as a troupe of male strippers. Billy Elliot falls squarely into the same triumph-over-trouble genre, but that is not to say that it should be written off as an imitation or a spinoff. For one thing, the film's young star, an exuberant, whirling dervish named Jamie Bell, is such a winning, witty screen presence that you can't help pulling for his plucky Billy. For another, the steely father (Gary Lewis) and the sulky brother (Jamie Draven) who oppose him sport vivid personalities of their own. For a third, Billy Elliot can be as howlingly funny as it is touching. If British filmmaking means to stage a comeback, it is likely to happen by way of nuanced, character-rich movies like this.
Daldry, a stage director making his movie debut, and screenwriter Lee Hall don't hesitate to load the deck emotionally--but that comes with the territory. That Billy's mother has died young comes as no great surprise; neither does the gruff, chain-smoking ballet teacher, Mrs. Wilkinson (Julie Walters), who takes a special interest in him. The moviemakers also provide the boy with a doddering grandmother (Jean Heywood) who imagines she could have been a great dancer, and a best friend (Stuart Wells) who turns out to be gay. Meanwhile, the movie takes pains to point out that Billy is resolutely hetero. When we first see this scrawny, disjointed kid in action, he's getting his clock cleaned at the local boys' boxing club; when he finds himself drawn instead to the girls' ballet class being conducted in the same gymnasium, he worries about it. "I feel like a sissy," he admits, his hormones obviously in preadolescent torment.
That's nothing compared to Dad's outrage when he discovers Billy spinning pirouettes. "Lads do football or boxing or wrestling," he rants, "not...ballet." The father spits the word out like an obscenity, and we know right away that the birth of this artist is going to involve some labor pains. Widowed, on strike, and frustrated, Dad has enough trouble putting food on the table. He doesn't need a son he thinks is a poof. Better he turns out to be Rocky Balboa.
Inevitably, familial love goes to battle with ignorance. When Mrs. Wilkinson, who has an eye for raw talent--if not much talent herself--urges Billy to follow his calling and audition for the Royal Ballet School in far-off London, the film's real crisis erupts. Will the young hero, uncertain about his own abilities, have the guts to be true to himself? Will the father be able to set prejudice aside and honor his son's dream? You don't need a film critic to answer such questions. Suffice it to say that director Daldry has a splendid way with actors and a keen eye for the comic potential and deeper meanings of a scene. Witness the Elliot family's heart-wrenching Christmas celebration, with the impoverished family wearing paper hats as they sit in their tiny kitchen, the mortified father barely containing his shame. Watch Dad open the family jewelry box, for reasons he could not have imagined. Exult in Billy and Dad's weird trip to alien London.
If there's more than a hint of hokiness in all this, so be it. Movies can (and most often do) commit worse sins than strumming away on our heartstrings. The strumming becomes not just palatable but downright enjoyable if it is decorated, as it is here, with some sharp observations on class warfare, the confusions of boyhood, and the stubbornness of provincial thought. Besides, who shouldn't be reminded once in a while that there's more than one way for Rocky to win a big fight?
Balletomanes won't confuse Billy Elliot with transcendent dance films like The Red Shoes or I Am a Dancer anytime soon, because the blue-eyed, jug-eared, sometimes splayfooted kid we meet here has trouble getting out of his own way for most of these 100 or so minutes. But it would be a mistake to undervalue Billy's enthusiasm, his need for escape, or the purity of his desire. As we know, from such small steps do great leaps spring.
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.