John Q. Archibald (Denzel Washington), a perfect working-class Everyman, is struggling just to make ends meet; bad turns to way worse when his 9-year-old son (Daniel E. Smith) is suddenly diagnosed with a heart defect that will kill him within weeks unless he can get a transplant. But John, who has always made sure that his family has adequate medical insurance, now discovers that his employer has cut back to a lower level of coverage that won't pay for his little boy's operation. Having exhausted all other options, John gets a gun and takes the cardiac surgeon (James Woods) and everyone in the emergency room hostage, demanding that Mike be placed on the heart-transplant waiting list, money be damned.
John Q. clearly aspires to couch discussion of a crucial social issue--the need for (and righteousness of) universal health care--in the garb of a palatable, mass-market thriller. It's a fine ambition, but one that the film, hampered by clunkiness on both fronts, only partly fulfills. The more commercial elements are often ham-fisted; at the same time, director Nick Cassavetes and writer James Kearns occasionally have the film grind to a halt for flat debate about the issues. The film does have its virtues, primarily among the performances. Washington is always worth watching, even in a role written with as few complexities as this one. Also aboard for the ride are Anne Heche (as a frosty hospital administrator), Robert Duvall (as a hostage negotiator) and Ray Liotta (as a camera-hungry chief of police).
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.