Carrie Underwood | Bo Bice
This year's edition of American Idol--the show's fourth season since igniting a tele-musical frenzy in 2002--was something of a triumph for the South: The program's two finalists, Oklahoma native Carrie Underwood and Alabama-born Bo Bice, proved that Dixie denizens could compete with contestants from flashier locales, and that music with a twang had a chance against sugary pop-rock and high-gloss R&B.
On Some Hearts winner Underwood seems utterly uninterested in ditching the crowd-pleasing approach emphasized by the show; this is the sort of nouveau-Nashville pop-country fluff doled out by megastars like Faith Hill and Shania Twain. But Underwood seems equally uninterested in clearing a space for herself in that commercial thicket. Beyond "Jesus, Take the Wheel," a fascinatingly overwrought ballad about finding God in the middle of a car accident, there's nothing in the music here to rival Twain's cowgirl spunk or Hill's soccer-mom spark.
Hirsute runner-up Bice is more distinctive on The Real Thing, even if his Southern-rock shtick ends up as airbrushed as Underwood's. Hiring the right song doctors helped: Nickelback frontman Chad Kroeger's "You're Everything" ripples with bubblegrunge muscle, while "Nothing Without You," co-written by Jon Bon Jovi, is a tasty prom-rock confection. Bice may live to shave another day.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene with music features, additional online music listings and show picks. We'll also send special ticket offers and music promotions available only to our Music Newsletter subscribers.