A Cosmic Joke isn't as boring as you'd expect a Salim Nourallah-produced Chris Holt record to be.
Faint praise, sure. But it says a lot about the two Dallas music-scene lifers.
For all their accolades—Holt's as a multi-year Dallas Observer Music Award winner for his guitar and keyboard prowess and general musicianship, and Nourallah's as a DOMA-winning producer—both tend toward slick, conservative and almost-too-professional play and recordings.
As expected, this disc contains a few forgettable, intricately finger-picked, rhyming-dictionary-assisted folk compositions, surprising only in how unrelenting the self-pitying tone is. Yet a few songs actually manage to evoke an emotional response, such as "Always In Awe," an ode to Holt's late Sorta bandmate, Carter Albrecht. Holt's hushed vocals and a gentle, melancholy melody say as much or more about the wearisome grieving of a friend and role model than the sweetly simple, and sometimes clumsy words do. But the mood turns bitter with the next track, "Aim High," a spewing of accusations clearly aimed at the neighbor whose fearful trigger finger ended Albrecht's life: "Where's your remorse for what you've done?" Holt snarls in the chorus. That ugliness is almost redeemed by the string-accented "Say Goodbye," which is minimal, unadorned and raw, just like the rest of the album's better tracks.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene with music features, additional online music listings and show picks. We'll also send special ticket offers and music promotions available only to our Music Newsletter subscribers.