My Morning Jacket
The first few tracks of My Morning Jacket's fifth studio album, Evil Urges, sound like a cruel put-on, with lead singer Jim James adopting the Prince-inspired falsetto he first toyed with on Z's "Wordless Chorus" for entire songs—only to have it come across more like a bad Ween joke than a recklessly brilliant Beck experiment.
Sure, the band reverts back to more familiar territory as the album progresses, rocking out "Mahgeetah"-style on the propulsive "Aluminum Park" and dabbling in gorgeous, blue-eyed soul on "Sec Walkin'" and the sexy, thoughtful "Librarian," which is easily the disc's best track.
But with the band's trademark gravy-thick reverb dialed down this time around, the ugly truth becomes apparent: When you lift the veil of magical echo that coats most of MMJ's greatest songs, you'll find Jim James, at best, a serviceable lyricist. As he once sang on 2001's near classic At Dawn, "It's just the way that he sings/Not the words that he says, or the band." But, honestly, when James, circa 2008, is busy singing about a "peanut butter pudding surprise" on the frat-party ready "Highly Suspicious" or conjuring an elementary school graduation on the Seals and Crofts-ish "Thank You Too" ("I want to see you for all that you do/I want to thank you") it's hard to give a shit anymore, no matter how pretty it is.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene with music features, additional online music listings and show picks. We'll also send special ticket offers and music promotions available only to our Music Newsletter subscribers.