KPMG Sued For Giving Tom Hicks "Clean Audit" a Year Before $525-Million Loan Default
Courthouse News has the lawsuit: GSP Finance LLC v. KPMG LLC, an alphabet soup's worth of names that sounds thoroughly uninteresting. Until, that is, you crack open the case and discover that GSP Finance is the lending arm of Galatioto Sports Partners -- the same company Hicks hired in February 2010 to find prospective investors in or a buyer for the Dallas Stars after Hicks Sports Group defaulted on that $525 million in loans in the spring of '09. Says the suit, GSP Finance loaned Hicks's HSG Sports Group $67 million based upon KPMG's audit, which said everything was fine even though it was far from.
The suit was filed yesterday in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, and in it GPS alleges that KPMG "was well aware of the desperate financial condition of Hicks Sports" -- specifically, the Texas Rangers and Dallas Stars -- when it was hired to conduct the '08 audit. From the suit, which goes on to detail HSG's losses beginning in 2003:
Given access to all of Hicks Sports' financial records, KPMG knew that Hicks Sports lacked the capacity to meet its obligations as they came due and was in breach of a covenant in the credit agreements limiting the debt total it was permitted to assume ("Debt Covenant"). Despite the knowledge, KPMG disregarded the professional duties it owed to GSP and its lenders, and fraudulently issued a clean audit opinion to Hicks Sports.
KPMG's fraud inflicted significant losses on GPS and the lenders. Had KPMG exercised professional due care, its March 31, 2008 independent auditor's report would have disclosed both Hicks Sports' inability to continue as a going concern and its breach of the Debt Covenant. Hicks Sports' failure to obtain a clean audit opinion and certification of its compliance with the Debt Covenant would have resulted in a default of the credit agreement. This would have permitted the lenders to exercise several rights to ensure full repayment of the loans, including terminating the credit agreements and asserting control over the equity interested Hicks Sports held in the Stars and Rangers.
The suit says Hicks Sports Group suffered losses of $113 million in 2002, $67.8 million in '03 and $95 million in '04. Till the Stars are sold, it won't be clear exactly how much Hicks's lenders have lost. But we know they netted around $300 million from the sale of the Rangers last summer.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss Observer's biggest stories.