Greatest Hits

Regina Chellew is sitting in Tami Thomsen's office at Last Beat Records on Commerce Street, talking about her new album. It is her solo debut, released under the name Chao, and, for the most part, it is a true solo effort, with Chellew recording almost every note on the disc. But from what she says, it's clear that the album she's talking about, Hitsthemiss, isn't new at all. Not to Chellew, at least.

Chellew played almost all of the 11 songs on Hitsthemiss, at one time or another, with her band Captain Audio, and most of them, she explains, existed long before there was a Captain Audio. She's had them with her for a long time, carrying them from project to project, like an unpacked box that moves from apartment to apartment. They were songs she sketched out at home and left there, more often than not. Even the pair of tunes she covers on the disc, Bob Dylan's "Lay Lady Lay" (a duet with Pleasant Grove's Marcus Striplin) and a codeine-coated take on The Ramones' "I Wanna Be Sedated," were there--in theory, anyway--for years. While Captain Audio performed some of them, the real versions stayed in her head, the only place where they sounded right. Once other people got their hands on them, they weren't Chellew's songs anymore.

In a way, then, Hitsthemiss is something of a reclamation project rather than a solo record, a chance for Chellew to take back all of these songs and do them the way she always wanted to, get them out of her system before taking her next step. Hitsthemiss isn't the next step it appears to be at first glance; she didn't write these songs with the intention of turning them into a solo disc. Chellew only started to head in that direction when the group didn't want them.

For example: One of the songs on Hitsthemiss, "Bugs," appeared on a five-song demo Captain Audio sold at shows in its infancy. Chellew wasn't completely satisfied with the rough version the group laid down, and the band never made another pass at it. When Hitsthemiss came about, Chellew finally had a chance to finish it, to make the sound on the tape match the one she heard in her head.

"It's something I wrote in 1992, '93, so I've had it for years," Chellew explains. "And it's gone through all kinds of different changes and evolutions, and it was just something I needed to do. I wanted it done. I'm tired of it, really. A lot of the stuff on the record, to me, is really old. I have a lot of new material. I'm ready to move on and do other things. It's a good place to start, this record. A good place to put that song."

If things had gone another way, the place to put those songs would have been on one of Captain Audio's two releases, 1999's My ears are ringing but my heart's ok EP or last year's full-length LUXURY or whether it is better to be loved than feared. Hitsthemiss certainly sounds like it could be a Captain Audio record, which just shows how much Chellew brought to the group. Like Captain Audio, the songs have a simple complexity, an ability to play by the rules and ignore them at the same time. Chellew glides from genre to genre with the ease of a CD changer, each step as logical and unexpected as the one before it. Yet even with its eclectic nature, the songs on Hitsthemiss manage to cohere into a seamless whole, not unlike Legendary Crystal Chandelier's similarly diverse Beyond Indifference. The disc may flirt with other styles of music, but they remain true to Chellew's personal vision, a trick that manages to make even the cover songs sound like Chellew originals.

While the fingerprints of Captain Audio are all over Hitsthemiss, except for "Bugs," the band never got around to recording any of these songs. It was frustrating for Chellew, watching some of her songs fall by the wayside. And that's the problem when three talented musicians try to squeeze themselves into the confines of a rock band, even one as loose and liberal as Captain Audio. The group--on indefinite hiatus as Brandon Curtis and Josh Garza play with their new group, The Secret Machines, in New York--always had more ideas than enough time and space to explore them. My ears are ringing but my heart's ok and LUXURY or whether it is better to be loved than feared sounded like mix tapes made by someone with a perfect record collection, selections from the five-disc boxed set that existed only in the group's rehearsal space. Trying to fit everything they wanted to do on one album or into one show was a bit like breaking into a bank vault with only enough time to take what you can carry. Inevitably, some treasure is left behind.