But look: These last couple of weeks, a stark reality has been staring me in the face. If the Blackwood proposal to get rid of the city manager system in favor of a strong mayor fails, then Dallas goes downhill. Faster. A Blackwood defeat will be much worse than a victory for the status quo. We'll be on a toboggan ride aimed straight at that big old tree at the bottom of the hill. The Failure Oak.
The system we have now feeds failure. It robs the people who take part in it of their dignity. If Blackwood goes down, the defeat will endorse that system. I can't imagine a worse outcome.
Let me share a thought that popped into mind last week when the agonizing story of former Dallas police *surfaced again briefly in the news. City lawyers were in court trying to get a judge to toss out Bolton's unfair firing suit. Seeing him on TV again ripped a slow-healing psychic wound. The saga of the city's first black chief--especially the denouement with the chief sobbing in pain on television--was just horrible. Awful. I would like to live out the rest of my life and never see that again.
But here is what occurred to me when I saw his face on TV last week: You know what? If a strong-mayor system had already been in place when Bolton was first in office, Mayor Laura Miller would have sacked him right between the eyes, right away. Blammo! You are so fired!
And by now Bolton would be the police chief in another major metropolitan area. He would have put his stuff in a box and moved on with honor. Instead, he's a man so mortally wounded I honestly question whether he can continue to work in his chosen field.
Why did that happen? Hey, see if we can forget for one minute the who-shot-John stuff and who's right and who's wrong on the specifics. Sometimes people get canned. It's America. This is a free country. We have a right to work where we want. Under most circumstances, the people we work for have a right to can us. Nobody ever knows for sure whether it's totally absolutely 100 percent fair. The fair comes to town once a year, and maybe we should reserve the word for that season. Firings just happen. Life goes on; people go on.
What wounded Bolton so badly was not the firing but the dragging out, the horrible indecisiveness, the maybe-he-should-go, maybe-he-should-not. Nobody can survive that junk. This wretched excuse for a system takes good people and bad people and in-the-middle people, and it twists them all up into the same big ball of indecision and uncertainty. It makes everybody look horrible.
Some really bright people work for the city, by the way. The current city manager, Mary Suhm, who started more than 25 years ago as a city librarian, could run a major company with one hand tied behind her back--exactly what she'll wind up doing, I bet, if she gets bounced out by Blackwood.
But at least if she does get bounced by Blackwood, she'll get a clean bounce. There's such a thing as an involuntary departure with honor. The way it is now, even the good people on the city staff just flail and swim and gulp for air until the quicksand gets them. It's horrible to watch.
This is not only about giving the mayor more power. Beth Ann Blackwood, the lawyer whose name is on the charter proposal, has explained it more as assigning greater accountability to the mayor, so that the buck will stop somewhere.
You and I need to be able to say two things to City Hall: 1) We don't have time to follow what you do down there in detail; 2) but if it comes out ugly, we're going to blame the mayor.
Under the existing system, all of them--all of the elected officials, including the mayor--can crab-walk away from any issue in which they don't see a personal political payoff. They do it all the time.
Example: In recent months, I've been tracking the issue of a second regional rail line through downtown. Haven't heard about that one yet? Yeah, and that's amazing, because guess what? This single issue is as big in impact for Dallas as rebuilding Central Expressway in the '80s or the creation of the Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport in the late 1960s.
Pop quiz: Did you know we have to build a subway? Right. We do. The city council has been briefed on it. There's no other way to weave together all the new rail lines about to come through downtown. But did you know we can wind up with a really bad subway or a good one, based on decisions the council is going to make in the next few weeks?