Film Reviews

Cock of the walk

Magnolia, the third film from writer-director Paul Thomas Anderson, is a brilliant piece of garbage -- mesmerizing, but only because you can't believe someone has the temerity to put so much into so little. Three hours and eight minutes long, and all it has to say at the end is this: Your past always has a way of catching up with you, of betraying you, of condemning and, ultimately, ruining you. It says it a dozen different ways, through the mouths of a dozen different characters -- each one more pathetic than the next, each so tormented that he or she always speaks as though a nervous breakdown is just around the bend. That is, when they're not crying already -- sobbing hysterically, more often than not, their words either stuck in their throats or drenched in so many tears, they're nearly unintelligible. Anderson likely penned his epic script on Kleenex.

For a film about the deep scars of past actions, Magnolia is extraordinarily shallow -- pretty to look at (at least, more so than Anderson's MTV infomercials for girlfriend Fiona Apple), because beauty obscures a multitude of sins. That is Anderson's lot in life, to make exceptional films and bury them beneath so much errata and clutter, they become all but unwatchable junkyards. Bless the patient soul with the fortitude to sit through Anderson's movies in hope of extracting those astonishing 43 minutes from the rest of the scrap heap. Find someone who thought the final hour of Boogie Nights was worth suffering through, and you'll find someone waiting only for the long-discussed payoff -- a 13-inch rubber dick, dangling lifelessly from Mark Wahlberg's crotch. Anderson apparently thinks longer is better in every way.

Only Anderson would build a film around Tom Cruise, then inhume him deep beneath the rubble. Here, Cruise is nothing but a bit player, when, in truth, he is the star of this ensemble piece, overshadowing -- no, mowing down -- anyone who shares a scene with him. Finally, after so many years of wasting his star quality in films beneath or beyond him (Eyes Wide Shut, most recently and most notably), Cruise owns a movie -- and the director doesn't have sense enough to give it to him.

Anderson probably thinks John C. Reilly's lonely good cop, Los Angeles police officer Jim Kurring, is the film's moral center; after all, Kurring almost narrates the movie, speaking to himself as though he were narrating an episode of COPS. "As we move through this life, we should try to do good," Kurring says early on, offering one of dozens of fortune-cookie platitudes he and others have the chance to utter. (Other highlights: "The most useless thing in the world is that which is behind me" and "The past is not through with us.") Or perhaps Anderson thinks the movie belongs to Melora Walters, who plays Claudia Gator Wilson, the strung-out daughter of drunken, lecherous game-show host Jimmy Gator (played by Philip Baker Hall, one of many Anderson regulars to appear in Magnolia).

Or, or, or...the list goes on: William H. Macy as pathetic Quiz Kid Donnie Smith, a former game-show wunderkind dressed in Target's Duran Duran line; Jason Robards as the slowly dying Earl Partridge, drawing his final breaths from a machine; Julianne Moore as Earl's guilt-ridden trophy wife Linda; Philip Seymour Hoffman as Phil Parmer, Earl's nurse and the man charged with absolving the old man of his sins; and Jeremy Blackman as the game-show child prodigy who craves only a tiny bit of his old man's affections. "I want you to be nicer to me," the kid tells his father; pretty much sums it all up.

But through it all, only Tom Cruise stands out -- perhaps because he's the only actor given a chance to exist beyond Anderson's sophomoric script. He is absolutely riveting as Frank T.J. Mackey, an evangelist for the lonely and horny male -- and, yes, the long-lost son of one Earl Partridge (making Magnolia one more in a never-ending string of Cruise's Daddy Movies). Frank makes his entrance to the overwrought strains of "Also Sprach Zarathustra," and like the monolith in 2001: A Space Odyssey, Frank attracts anyone caught in his orbit. As the founder of Seduce and Destroy, he preaches the gospel of the erection: "Respect the cock, and tame the cunt" is his motto, which he tells his hooting-and-hollering legions while stalking the stage, strapped in beneath a leather vest and sporting a belt-buckle watch. Standing in front of a banner that reads, "No pussy has nine lives," Cruise exudes such confidence and such misogyny -- the man is a walking hard-on in search of someone to fuck, or fuck over. "I'm an action hero," he says, and you believe him; the man's got a kung-fu grip.

KEEP THE DALLAS OBSERVER FREE... Since we started the Dallas Observer, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Dallas, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Robert Wilonsky
Contact: Robert Wilonsky