Until two months ago, Jourdan Aldredge ran a Facebook page with 140,000 followers. In early August, Facebook removed the page, which linked to Aldredge's movie club web page.
Since then, Aldredge has been trying to figure out what happened.
The website, Ultimate Action Movie Club, is a curated collection of articles and trivia about 1980s and 1990s action movies. The Facebook page functioned as a community and drove traffic to the website. Although the club's Instagram, Twitter and Reddit are still up, Aldredge has noticed roughly a 50% drop in traffic since the Facebook page came down.
“We don't make a lot of money; it's just like a side thing,” said Aldredge, a former Dallas Observer contributor and Austin-based writer and filmmaker. “If I was relying on it full time, that would be pretty devastating.”
In August, Aldredge flew to Belize for a friend's wedding. Not long after he arrived, Facebook notified him that his location had been changed to Belize. It's well-documented that Facebook tracks user locations and Aldredge thought it was odd, but he didn't pay the notice much mind.
But the next morning, Aldredge received the email that his Facebook page had been removed.
“A Facebook Page is a distinct presence used solely for business or promotional purposes. Among other things, Pages that are hateful, threatening, or obscene are not allowed. We also take down Pages that attack an individual or group, or that are set up by an unauthorized individual. If your Page was removed for any of the above reasons, it will not be reinstated,” the email reads.
None of the reasons above seem to apply to Aldredge's page, on which he said he enforced strict standards of decorum.
The Belize trip was Aldredge's first international trip in the several years he's run the page, and he wonders if somehow traveling outside the country triggered Facebook to shut the page down. The page's content — article links with movie stills and trailers — should be covered under fair use law, which allows for this kind of use in journalism and blogging.
Other movie club sites, like the A.V. Club, with a half-million followers, and Bloody Disgusting, with more than a million followers, maintain Facebook pages with similar content to what was on the Ultimate Action Movie Club page. Perhaps most confusing, a copycat page started by someone else is still up and functional on Facebook.
Facebook did not return repeated requests for comment on this article.
Aldredge started the Ultimate Action Movie Club in high school with some friends. During the era when Blockbuster sold off all its old VHS tape movies, the group of friends began collecting and critiquing cheesy action movies they found. Parsing Chuck Norris and Jean-Claude Van Damme flicks was a fun group activity.
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to the Observer's mission. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Dallas's stories with no paywalls.
Support Our Journalism
Years later, Aldredge started the Facebook page to continue the conversation online and eventually added the website and other social media. The page and community have been growing ever since.
“We were at the point where it might be almost a full-time thing,” he said.
But now Aldredge can't find answers to what happened or get another page going, since Facebook blocked his second one. With no path to recourse with Facebook, there aren't many options, other than focusing on his other social media platforms and the website itself.
“I'm kind of at the point where I've given up,” he said.