Courtesy of Banana Ball
Audio By Carbonatix
Fisher Polydoroff isn’t your average Texas ballplayer. As a 20-year-old athlete who hails from Keller, he has gone from local select leagues and a full scholarship at Weatherford College to becoming the youngest player ever signed by the viral Savannah Bananas organization. But Polydoroff’s journey stands out for more than just his fast track through baseball. He’s also a multi-talented linguist, musician and entertainer. Now, he’s bringing his unique flair to the newly revived Indianapolis Clowns.
Instead of following the traditional route to professional baseball, Polydoroff is making history with one of the sport’s most storied clubs. By joining the Indianapolis Clowns, he becomes not just a Bananas recruit but a new face in the revival of a team that helped pioneer the fusion of baseball with entertainment.
The Clowns were legends of the Negro Leagues, barnstorming pioneers who blended breathtaking baseball with laugh-out-loud entertainment long before “fans first” was a marketing slogan. They were the original baseball rockstars, laying a foundation of joy and showmanship that the Savannah Bananas have built their empire upon. Now, they’re back, and a kid from Keller is at the heart of the revival.
This year, make your gift count –
Invest in local news that matters.
Our work is funded by readers like you who make voluntary gifts because they value our work and want to see it continue. Make a contribution today to help us reach our $30,000 goal!
For Polydoroff, this is not a lucky break. It’s destiny unfurling like a perfectly thrown banner.
“I guess everything in my life has been leading up to me being a perfect candidate for Banana Ball,” he tells the Observer. “It’s truly special that I found a niche in Banana Land at a time where no one was doing vintage baseball impersonations and impressions.”
His journey to this point is as eclectic as the collection of instruments he’s mastered (over 12, by the way). A standout player for the Texas Stix and Keller High School, he honed his skills on local fields before landing a full-ride scholarship to play for the top-ranked Weatherford College. He was on the traditional path, the one that leads to draft days and minor league bus rides. But Polydoroff is wired differently. While his peers were studying scouting reports, he was also studying the discography of The Stylistics, teaching himself ancient Chinese flutes and crafting an on-field persona that felt ripped from a sepia-toned photograph.
That persona is “Ole Knuckles,” a time-traveling ballplayer pulled straight from the 1950s. Inspired by players like Satchel Paige, the Ole Knuckles character is an extension of Polydoroff’s soul.
“I felt like there was no better person on planet Earth to portray this role and character in Banana Ball,” he explains.
He walked away from the security of his college scholarship to bet on himself by attending the final Banana Ball tryout of the season in Kansas City, adopting a ’50s accent along the way. It was a risk that paid off in spades. He wasn’t just chosen; he was a unanimous selection, only the second time in Banana Ball history that’s ever happened.
He arrived in Savannah fully committed to the bit, a walking, talking, knuckleball-throwing piece of vintage Americana.
Courtesy of Banana Ball
And now, Ole Knuckles has found his home. The Indianapolis Clowns were standouts of the Negro Leagues, famous for their “shadow ball” routines and comedic flair, all while fielding Baseball Hall of Fame talent like Hank Aaron. It’s a legacy Polydoroff feels he was born to continue. He speaks with reverence about researching the old barnstorming teams and their traveling shows.
It’s a history he’s not just honoring, but reliving. One childhood Christmas, long before Banana Ball was a twinkle in his eye, his father gifted him an Indianapolis Clowns hat because of his fascination with the Negro Leagues. The universe, it seems, was dropping hints.
“It truly is a dream gig because I just exemplify the vintage nostalgia of America’s pastime,” Polydoroff says.
The Keller native’s journey isn’t simply a baseball story. It’s a tale of a North Texas kid who refused to be put in a box. In a world that demands routine specialization, Polydoroff chose to be a Renaissance man in his own way. He speaks three languages. He plays the accordion, trumpet, clarinet and multiple saxophones. He has a catalog of over 50 original songs and dreams of bringing African-American doo-wop music into the Banana Ball experience. In his spare time, he performs ’50s music for seniors in retirement homes, an act that is equal parts community service and character research.
“I think all of my life I’ve been trying to fortify my repertoire and diversify my kind of resume of life, skills and talents and hobbies,” he reflects.
That resume is now getting its biggest stage. The Banana Ball World Tour sells out major league stadiums, a cultural phenomenon with millions of followers. The revival of the Clowns, in partnership with the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, adds a layer of historical weight and cultural significance.
As Ryan Howard, World Series champion and the Clowns’ Primetime coach, put it in a press statement, the Negro Leagues were “rockstars before the world called ballplayers that.” Fisher Polydoroff, with his larger-than-life personality and deep love for the game’s history, seems ready to be their modern-day frontman.
He’s bringing a piece of DFW with him along the way — the grit learned on select fields from age eight to 18, the work ethic from Keller High School and the swagger of a Texan who knows he has something special to offer. Polydoroff’s story is a poetic reminder that the most exciting paths are often the ones you have to carve yourself. He’s taking a swing that’s bigger than baseball, aiming for a legacy that blends sports, music, history and pure, unadulterated joy. For the kid from Keller who found his calling playing a man out of time, the future is a beautiful, unpredictable and very entertaining game.
