Craig Watkins: Josh Brent's Light Sentence Due to "Affluenza," Friendly, Majority-Minority Jury

There are some obvious parallels between Ethan Couch and Josh Brent. Both got drunk and caused fatal car wrecks. Both had the means to hire talented private attorneys. Both were given offensively light sentences that sparked outrage.

To most observers, that's where the similarities end. Couch is white, Brent black. Couch is still legally a kid; Brent's a grown man. The mother of Brent's victim has forgiven him. The families of Couch's victims (there were four) have not.

Dallas County District Attorney Craig Watkins, though, thinks the fates of the privileged Tarrant County teen and the former Dallas Cowboy are more closely connected than they might appear. In an interview with K104, reported by WFAA's Carla Wade, Dallas County District Attorney Craig Watkins blamed Couch's "affluenza" case for Brent's light sentence.

"The reason I firmly believe that the affluenza case influenced people, we're in the MLK parade and people are yelling, 'Hey free Josh Brent!' And 'Man, give him probation," he told the radio station. "That other guy killed four people.'"

See also: Keller Teen Gets Probation for Drunken Wreck that Killed 4, Pissing Off Just About Everyone

The jury was receptive to such arguments, Watkins says, because of its racial makeup: five black, three Hispanic, four white.

"Race still plays a factor," Watkins said. "Now that we have individuals that are of color and have the opportunity to serve on juries and decide a person's guilt or innocence, now we are seeing the opposite effect. And so the past, basically, is dictating the future."

He promises to "continue to fight and make sure that the system is fair for everyone and until that happens, then we will have verdicts like O.J. Simpson and like Josh Brent."

Yep. Watkins is playing the O.J. card, which ranks only slightly above Hitler allusions in the universe of legitimate legal arguments.

See also: Ethan Couch Should Have Gone to Prison, but Justice? There's No Justice for Texas Kids.

The main problem with that line of argument, as former Dallas County prosecutor Toby Shook/Watkins nemesis points out to Wade, is that Brent was convicted. Also: O.J. Simpson? Really?

Send your story tips to the author, Eric Nicholson.

KEEP THE DALLAS OBSERVER FREE... Since we started the Dallas Observer, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Dallas, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Eric Nicholson
Contact: Eric Nicholson