Audio By Carbonatix
Still No. 1. Despite the gaffes.
After that Monday night shootout – and considering they were 1-3 in last week’s rankings — anyone see a legit reason I shouldn’t have the Cowboys’ Tony Romo and Philly’s Donovan McNabb 1-2 this week?
Also impressive last weekend: Denver’s Jay Cutler and Green Bay’s Aaron Rodgers. At the other end of the spectrum: Jon Kitna is a quitter, Tarvaris Jackson might be replaced by Gus Frerotte and is there any doubt that the Chiefs’ collection of misfits – how about four quarterbacks in two weeks — is the worst in the league?
Romo, however, needs to eliminate his silly mistakes. An interception in the end zone last week. A double-bobble-fumble in his own end zone this week. If these rankings were purely for entertainment value, Romo might be both 1 and 2.
Everyone loves quarterbacks. Sports geeks love rankings. I love criticism. It’s the perfect marriage.
This week’s roll call after you jump:
1. Tony Romo – Cowboys
2. Donovan McNabb — Eagles
3. Ben Roethlisberger – Steelers
4. Peyton Manning – Colts
5. Aaron Rodgers – Packers
6. Jay Cutler – Broncos
7. Eli Manning – Giants
8. Philip Rivers — Chargers
9. Kurt Warner – Cardinals
10. Jake Delhomme – Panthers
11. Drew Brees – Saints
12. Brett Favre – Jets
13. Jason Campbell – Redskins
14. Trent Edwards – Bills
15. Kerry Collins – Titans
16. Matt Ryan – Falcons
17. Jon Kitna – Lions
18. Derek Anderson – Browns
19. Brian Griese – Buccaneers
20. Chad Pennington – Dolphins
21. Carson Palmer – Bengals
22. Matt Hasselbeck – Seahawks
23. Marc Bulger – Rams
24. David Garrard – Jaguars
25. Matt Cassel – Patriots
26. Matt Schaub – Texans
27. Kyle Orton – Bears
28. JaMarcus Russell – Raiders
29. JT O’Sullivan – 49ers
30. Tarvaris Jackson — Vikings
31. Joe Flacco – Ravens
32. Tyler Thigpen – Chiefs — Richie Whitt
