Unless they happen to be the city of Dallas' paid defense attorneys, it's hard to find a lawyer who thinks the city of Dallas has a shot at winning the lawsuit brought by Three Expo Events following the City Council decision to ban the Three Expo's Exxxotica sex show from the Kay Bailey Hutchison Convention Center.
Warren Ernst, Dallas' city attorney, isn't representing the city in the case because he'd already issued an opinion saying that the council's potential banning of Exxxotica was unconstitutional before the council did it anyway. Scott Griggs and Philip Kingston, both lawyers and both council members, were strongly against the ban. Kingston said Dallas' best strategy in the case was to "give up as quickly as possible." When asked to handicap the outcome of the suit, Dallas appellate lawyer Chad Ruback said that, despite the city's response to the suit — which includes lurid descriptions of alleged illegal acts at Exxxotica 2015 — Dallas, the mayor and the seven additional council members who voted for the ban are going to get "spanked."
No one was arrested for any of the alleged bad acts at last year's convention, Ruback says, and any attempted pre-emption of anything that might happen this year would amount to a prior restraint of constitutionally protected speech, something courts frown upon. It's not enough, he said, that the city didn't ban Exxxotica outright from the city limits. Because Dallas is in the convention business and the convention center is the only space the city provides for that business to be conducted, the city must allow the convention hall to be used for all legal speech, Ruback says.
The mayor doesn't view things through the same lens.
"We came to a place as a city where I had to make a judgement call. The reason I made it was because I saw some of the YouTube [videos from last year's event] and said, 'Look, I'm mayor of this city, I'm against domestic violence and we've got an S&M thing going on. How do I feel about it? I've gotta vote against that and let the judges do their job," Rawlings said. "We've got insurance on this, we self-insure, so we're not taking money away from the streets or poor hungry children, this is why we put an insurance package together over [at the convention center] for that enterprise fund and we'll let the judges make the call and we'll move on down the road."
Rawlings says he's asking questions about why those at the 2015 convention who might have committed public obscenity violations weren't arrested, too.
"I knew that our police activity was really limited. ... When the [Dallas Police Vice Squad] was there, they were just there for an hour here and an hour there to make sure nobody was dead," Rawlings said. "This stuff was happening in corners. Look, we should've found that out, but the bigger thing is, a company entered into a contract saying that wasn't going to happen and it did happen.
"We have the authority [to instruct the city manager not to enter into contracts]. I'm not saying that authority will hold up in court in this case. I'll honor a judge's point of view there, but there's enough logic that [Exxxotica] is a sexually oriented business. It's like saying, 'Oh my God, there's gambling in Casablanca.' Really, it's amazing to think 'Oh my God, there's nudity at a porn convention. I'm so shocked.' It's like, 'Of course there is.'" Rawlings said.
As a temporary use of the convention center, both Ernst and Ruback have said that the city's sexually oriented business ordinance does not apply to Exxxotica. Exxxotica's response to the city's filing in the case is due in about 10 days.
Keep the Dallas Observer Free... Since we started the Dallas Observer, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Dallas, and we would like to keep it that way. Offering our readers free access to incisive coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with gutsy reporting, stylish writing, and staffers who've won everything from the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with local journalism's existence under siege and advertising revenue setbacks having a larger impact, it is important now more than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Dallas with no paywalls.